A Fabulous Mind
Author uses lengthy detailed descriptions of her privileged and extremely supportive family as an introduction to herself as a person, and even a definition of who she is. As if the origin and class of the family could ensure the quality of the human being.
Emphasizing her waspiness throughout the book, she demonstrates beliefs in her perfection and even imperviousness. When the time comes to accept her diagnosis, she remains in denial, because she cannot accept the idea that something is wrong with her.
Author's family story holds many contradictions. She mentions her mother and her brother, who help her to overcome depression, but her father and her sister "disappear" right after she gets diagnosed. Readers later learn that her father drinks and that is that. How can this perfect supportive family ever fall apart? Has it ever been that connected?
The fact that Dr. Jamison has been diagnosed by her coworker tells something about her self-knowledge and professionalism. As she describes her erratic behaviors and depressed mood prior to being diagnosed, she presents a clear manic-depressive state, yet she fails to make connections and recognize the symptoms (although at that level of training she should be able to). Even after the formal diagnosis she remains in denial until she cannot manage without lithium.
Dr. Jamison spends much time sharing her educational experiences and achievements (degrees, practicums, awards, etc.), as if she is writing a resume. Yet she fails to mention any of her clients, people she actually helped. The environment that surrounds Dr. Jamison revolves around her, exists for her, and it seems that the purpose of education in mental health is in having a career, getting tenure, publishing, and making money for travels. I sensed that in Dr. Jamison's grandiose personality there is not much compassion for other people who suffer and need help.
In fact, she does not even have a high opinion about them. As she puts it, it was humiliating to admit her disorder and go see a psychiatrist and "be on the other side". So, that's what it is, she sees potential help seekers as people who should be embarrassed because they lost their dignity to the disorder. Who would want to ask such a doctor for help?
In addition to this, the language and poetic inserts aren't that impressive. In fact, they are quite redundant. Multitude of expressive adjectives creates affective blobs here and there, but that creates more noise than emotional strength.
The truth is, this story is unremarkable. Author tries to make it into a glamorous account of mental illness, while minimizing its severity and impact on relationships. Bipolar disorder ceases to be brutal and draining experience; when Dr. Jamison has it, it becomes more sanitized and dignified. The suicide attempt reads like an unpleasant hitch that does not bring any revelation.
Dr. Jamison's attitude makes it impossible to empathize with her. She does not want her readers to see her being weak or helpless. All she wants is admiration.
Finally, in the epilogue author states that if she were to choose, she'd choose to have bipolar disorder, which to me manifests that the author just does not want to be average. She is afraid of being ordinary, one of many. To me, she is.
With so many incongruences, it is clear that this book is not what it claims to be. When you subtract the misrepresented mental illness, what remains is a poorly written fictionalized memoir.
2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.