"A comprehensive new biography of the fabled Sioux medicine man . . . [It] rattled me . . . [Black Elk's] fate was to survive a rolling catastrophe with eyes wide open, his luck also his curse." —Walter Kirn, Harper's Magazine
"Joe Jackson has expertly taken Black Elk’s life—as narrated by himself in the transcripts of his interviews with Neihardt—and woven that together with other records and histories of him and his times. The result is that Jackson has firmly situated Black Elk in the context of Indian struggles on the plains from 1850 through 1950. He uses Black Elk to bring home the radical changes that confronted most Indians during this time and, in doing so, creates a deeply felt and personal story of loss and change on the plains . . . the long set piece concerning the Battle of the Little Bighorn is among the very best I’ve ever read." —David Treuer, The Washington Post
"Remarkably thorough . . . Jackson’s deep research shows on every page, and his narrative skill makes this long biography a gripping, even thrilling read . . . In this book, he helps bring back a crucial American voice." —Kate Tuttle, The Boston Globe
"Black Elk stands out for its comprehensiveness, wide-ranging historical context, and the author's deftly apposite quotation from contemporary sources . . . In addition to seating Black Elk in his time and in the events he witnessed, Jackson gives a genuine sense of the inner man, the conflict in his soul between his Indian heritage and identity and his clear-sighted, hardnosed understanding of the compromises and capitulations necessary for his and the Lakota's survival . . . Drawing on immense research, Joe Jackson has given us the story of a man and a people whose land, way of life, and culture were the target of a concentrated project of extermination by the United States Government." —Katherine A. Powers, Critical Mass, the blog of the National Book Critics Circle Board of Directors
"Remarkably researched and beautifully told . . . Jackson gives us a modern man working his way through the obstacles of the 20th century . . . his research has rewards, shifting in subtle ways the stories we thought we knew." —Ann Fabian, The National Book Review
"An astonishingly rich saga . . . Jackson's biography works to represent 'the flesh-and-blood wicasa wakan' (holy man) . . . We see Black Elk balancing tradition and modernity, with fleeting but vivid scenes of him on a ferris wheel and in a movie house. We hear of struggles within subsequent generations over his legacy and Lakota identity more generally." —Christine Bold, The Times Literary Supplement
"With access to family members of Lakota spiritual leader Black Elk, investigative journalist-historian Joe Jackson's talents as a writer, interviewer and historian are all on full-display in Black Elk, the most evocative, empathetic and comprehensive biography ever written about the Sioux holy man." —True West magazine, "The Best of the West"
"Joe Jackson’s important biography of the visionary Black Elk is much more than the story of one man’s life. It is a sweeping, comprehensive, elegantly written history of white and Indian relations; bloody, deadly battles; and the steady, deliberate destruction by the U.S. government of the native culture, language, traditions and way of life . . . Black Elk is a crucial book. It is a rich, engrossing read that will educate, surprise and infuriate." —Laurie Hertzel, The Star Tribune (Minneapolis)
"An exhaustively researched and meticulously detailed biography of Black Elk . . . Drawing on new material culled from interviews with members of Black Elk’s family, Jackson presents the Native American mystic’s life as a story rather than as a dry historical record, offering vivid accounts of historical events at which Black Elk was present . . . Jackson’s account of the great medicine man’s life, legacy, and spiritual journey is especially timely." —Spirituality and Health magazine
"Joe Jackson argues convincingly that Black Elk's life offers rare, substantial evidence of accurate Native American history as opposed to popular mythology and deserves ongoing attention as such . . . It's a colorful story, too . . . Black Elk displays a Gump-like tendency to rub shoulders with the famous, most notably when he joins Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show and finds himself in England performing for Queen Victoria." —Jeff Guinn, The Dallas Morning News
"[A] stirring, wide-ranging biography of the Sioux elder whose testimonials underlay ‘one of the twentieth century’s most important documents on Native American culture’ . . . Jackson surveys a broad swath of world history to place the Lakota spiritual leader in that terribly eventful context, and he does excellent work in doing so . . . [Black Elk is] of much literary and historical merit and a fine addition to the shelves of anyone interested in this part of America’s unhappy past." —Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
"Jackson's enlightening account of this influential Sioux leader, whose life encompassed many landmark events of the tumultuous years of U.S. western expansion, leaves the reader in awe of Black Elk's struggle to help his people preserve their culture as their traditions, religion, and education were under constant and brutal attack." —Deborah Donovan, Booklist (starred review)
"Jackson panoramically renders a narrative as majestic as the American West in this fine account of the life of Black Elk, an Oglala Lakota holy man. With compassion and clarity, Jackson portrays Black Elk as a man haunted by his inability to make sense of the 'Great Vision' that came to him as a child . . . He brilliantly frames it with an incisive discussion of the creation of John Neihardt’s 1932 as-told-to-book, Black Elk Speaks. Jackson digs into Native American culture and what it meant for Black Elk to be a holy man, especially in light of his 1904 conversion to Catholicism. He has produced a major contribution to Native American history." —Publishers Weekly
"Now readers can rediscover the real Black Elk and the wise, haunted book that bears his name. Jackson’s biography . . . brings long-lost events into sharp focus, both before and after the birth of what Jackson calls ‘one of the twentieth century’s most important documents on Native American culture’ . . . A timely addition to a rich and troubled history." —Gregory McNamee, Kirkus Reviews "Interviews and Profiles"
"Sweeping in scope . . . Joe Jackson does a magnificent job of relating, explaining and commenting on [Black Elk’s] life in what is by far the most comprehensive biography of its subject to date. Jackson portrays Native Americans with a clear-eyed sympathy that avoids sentimentality, bringing historical figures such as Crazy Horse, Red Cloud and Sitting Bull to life and providing fascinating insights into Indian life, culture and, most notably, religion." —Timothy J. Lockhart, The Virginian-Pilot
"A masterpiece of American biographical reconstruction . . . Black Elk is an unapologetically sympathetic biography, for all its wide-ranging source-work. But even sinners need some sympathy, especially when it’s as smart as the sympathy offered here." —Steve Donoghue, Open Letters Monthly
"The holy man reconstructed in this nuanced, revisionist story was . . . one of American history's great voices for social justice . . . Jackson's prodigiously researched narrative excels at parsing . . . controversies." —Ann Neumann, The Baffler
"Thorough and engrossing . . . Jackson’s storytelling is nuanced and exciting, and readers will gain a deeper understanding of Black Elk’s life and the mark he left on history." —Elizabeth Rowe, Bookish
"Jackson’s fascinating biography tells the true story of this American holy man." —Tom Beer, Newsday
"Joe Jackson has penned an extraordinary history of Lakota warfare with the United States wrapped around a thorough biography of the legendary Black Elk. Outstanding." —Robert M. Utley, author of The Lance and the Shield: The Life and Times of Sitting Bull
"In Black Elk, Joe Jackson paints a vivid portrait of a figure that has often been shrouded in shadows. This extraordinary book will transform the way readers think about the history of the United States and its indigenous peoples." —Ari Kelman, author of A Misplaced Massacre: Struggling Over the Memory of Sand Creek, winner of the Bancroft Prize
09/15/2016
When John Neihardt's Black Elk Speaks: Being the Life Story of a Holy Man of the Oglala Sioux was published in 1932, it was scarcely noticed by readers. When republished in 1962, its spiritualism spoke to the emerging counterculture, thus becoming one of the most influential American Indian works of the 20th century. Jackson (The Thief at the End of the World) endeavors to extricate the historical Black Elk from the mythology surrounding his legacy. Black Elk (1863–1950) lived during the most turbulent time in Oglala Lakota history. He fought in the Battle of Little Big Horn, witnessed the death of his cousin Crazy Horse, traveled throughout Europe in Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West show, saw the terrible slaughter at Wounded Knee, and was ultimately forced onto a reservation with his tribe. Although a Lakota spiritual leader, he converted to Catholicism. Black Elk's life as legend emerged as his words were translated by his son for Neihardt, who wrote the story he wanted to write by prioritizing certain events and minimizing others, most notably Black Elk's religion. VERDICT This fascinating biography should be read alongside Black Elk Speaks as it contextualizes and reframes that earlier work. [See Prepub Alert, 5/23/16.]—John R. Burch, Campbellsville Univ. Lib., KY
Traber Burns provides a narrative performance that resides somewhere between that of a devoted professor and a wise storyteller. That’s fitting, because this is a deep, detailed historical document. The stories found here are many, but their overall resonance is important, and relevant to our understanding of the American West. The audiobook tells the story of Black Elk, the Native American whose life rose to wide prominence in BLACK ELK SPEAKS. However, this audiobook is the most definitive work chronicling Black Elk’s life, which led him through many historical events, some violent (consider the passage where Black Elk takes his first scalp, or the battles fought against Custer), until he took the role of holy man in his later years. S.P.C. © AudioFile 2017, Portland, Maine
★ 2016-08-21
Stirring, wide-ranging biography of the Sioux elder whose testimonials underlay “one of the twentieth century’s most important documents on Native American culture.”Born in the Powder River country in Wyoming, Hehaka Sapa, or Black Elk (1863-1950), was a Lakota Zelig who had been on hand at some of the key moments in the history of the Indian Wars. He was a confidant of Crazy Horse, a leader of the Sun Dance, a warrior at Wounded Knee, and, in between, a performer in Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West Show—and even, while touring Europe, briefly a suspect in the infamous Jack the Ripper killings. Jackson (Atlantic Fever: Lindbergh, His Competitors, and the Race to Cross the Atlantic, 2012, etc.) surveys a broad swath of world history to place the Lakota spiritual leader in that terribly eventful context, and he does excellent work in doing so, explaining the dynamics of medicine men in Sioux society (there were two classes of them, “war prophets” and “healers”) and the dynamics of an American popular culture that saw John Neihardt’s Black Elk Speaks grow from a memoir of modest sales to a kind of Bible of the New Age movement, which “would envelop everything related to Black Elk Speaks in a warm and fuzzy nimbus.” One of the best moments in a book marked by many is Jackson’s in-passing examination of the role of the American media in fueling the Indian Wars; another is his examination of the mystery of Black Elk’s conversion to Catholicism, having long been an advocate of traditional Lakota ways. In the course of his narrative, the author provides a parallel biography of Neihardt, Black Elk’s chronicler, who felt great affection for and attachment to his interlocutor even as various players in Indian country tried to drive a wedge between the two. Of much literary and historical merit and a fine addition to the shelves of anyone interested in this part of America’s unhappy past.
