Rough-Hewn Land: A Geologic Journey from California to the Rocky Mountains

Rough-Hewn Land: A Geologic Journey from California to the Rocky Mountains

by Keith Heyer Meldahl

NOOK Book(eBook)

$22.49 $29.95 Save 25% Current price is $22.49, Original price is $29.95. You Save 25%.
View All Available Formats & Editions

Available on Compatible NOOK Devices and the free NOOK Apps.
WANT A NOOK?  Explore Now

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780520949942
Publisher: University of California Press
Publication date: 11/15/2011
Sold by: Barnes & Noble
Format: NOOK Book
Pages: 320
File size: 15 MB
Note: This product may take a few minutes to download.

About the Author

Keith Heyer Meldahl is Professor of Geology at Mira Costa College in southern California. He is the author of Hard Road West: History and Geology along the Gold Rush Trail.

Read an Excerpt

Rough-Hewn Land

A Geologic Journey from California to the Rocky Mountains

By Keith Heyer Meldahl


Copyright © 2011 the Regents of the University of California
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-0-520-94994-2



The Farallon Islands poke like rotten teeth out of the Pacific Ocean thirty miles west of San Francisco. The islands get in the way of deep currents, forcing cold, nutrient-rich waters to the surface. Like garden fertilizer, the nutrients—iron, nitrate, and phosphate mostly—trigger blooms of tiny plant-like phytoplankton. Life converges on the plankton. Seabirds swarm the skies. Seals and sea lions crowd the shoal waters. Hunger pulls them toward the sea, but fear keeps them near the shore. The fat sea mammals form a 24/7 snack stand for Great White sharks. Boatloads of tourists motor out from San Francisco to bob on the swells, scanning the ocean with binoculars. If they're lucky, they'll have a Discovery Channel moment—the one where a 2000-pound shark erupts from the water with a seal twisting in its bloody jaws.

The Farallon Islands are made of granite. On the face of it that seems a dry fact, for granite is an exceedingly common rock. It forms much of the basement rock of the continents and the uplifted cores of many continental mountain ranges. But continental is the key word here. Granite is a continental rock. Finding it on an oceanic island is strange. You could spend your life wandering around Hawaii or Tahiti or most of the other islands of the Pacific and never find a speck of granite. What is a continental rock like granite doing out at sea on the Farallon Islands?

The unexpected answer comes when we compare the islands' granite to granite from mainland California. The granite of the Farallon Islands, it turns out, is nearly identical in age and chemistry to granite found in the southern Sierra Nevada—300 miles southeast and nearly 100 miles inland from the California coast. The Farallon Islands, in other words, appear to be pieces of the Sierra Nevada that have split away from the continent and wandered out to sea. The reason is the San Andreas fault. Starting about eighteen million years ago, motion along the fault snipped off a large piece of the southern Sierra Nevada and slid it northwest toward San Francisco. Salinian Block is the name given to this chunk of dispossessed Sierra Nevada granite. The block includes the Farallon Islands and much of coastal California north and south of San Francisco. If present trends continue, the Farallon Islands, riding with the Salinian Block, will arrive at the coast of Alaska in about seventy million years.

For many people, the notion of a big chunk of the southern Sierra Nevada presently offshore of San Francisco and drifting toward Alaska falls somewhere between disturbing and impossible. It's a fair reaction. It comes from viewing the Earth through the lens of human time—a perspective that gives the illusion of stability to a world that, over geologic time, is radically mobile. A flash of a strobe light on a dance floor gives the same illusion. The dancers in that microsecond appear frozen in place, even though they're actually in continual motion. In human time, the continents and ocean basins appear fixed and permanent. To know that the Atlantic Ocean is forty-three feet wider today than when Columbus crossed it lifts, just a little, the veil of our illusion. We need to tear that veil away to see the Earth as it really is. When we do that, we see a different planet. Continents don't stay put. They drift like loose barges across the face of the Earth. Where they tear apart, new ocean basins open. Where they crunch together, ocean basins disappear and mountains rise in their place.

This action happens because the Earth's outer rind is split into moving plates of rock (frontispiece figure). The plates range fifty to one hundred miles thick, and several hundred to several thousand miles across. They move, in various directions, a few inches each year (figure 1.1). Continents are not plates, but they form parts of some plates. The continents ride like passengers on the plates, going where the plates take them, rearranging the face of the Earth over geologic time. Just about every major geologic feature on Earth—including volcanoes, earthquakes, mountain belts, metal and mineral deposits, and the large-scale features of the ocean floor—results from the movements of these plates. This discovery, called plate tectonics, stands at the pinnacle of human insight, shoulder-to-shoulder with biological evolution, the structure of the atom, quantum physics, and the expansion of the universe. Its power undergirds nearly everything that we'll explore in this book. The Earth's moving plates have written the story of the American West.

* * *

As you leave the Farallon Islands and ride the swells back to San Francisco, the first piece of the mainland to loom out of the fog is usually Point Bonita, a small peninsula that pokes like a crooked finger into the Golden Gate. A lighthouse at the tip of the point warns ship captains to steer clear of the dark cliffs and skerries that shatter the Pacific swells to white. The rock of Point Bonita is not granite but pillow basalt: greenish-black volcanic lava taking the form of pillow-sized blobs stacked upon one another like sacks of grain (figure 1.2).

The pillow basalt at Point Bonita and the granite of the Farallon Islands are utterly different rocks; you would more easily confuse Martin Luther King, Jr. and Eleanor Roosevelt. But they have one thing in common—they have both traveled a long way. In fact, the Point Bonita pillow basalt has traveled several thousand miles to end up here at the Golden Gate—a tectonic journey that makes the wandering granite of the Farallon Islands seem a homebody by comparison. The pillow basalt testifies to an epic tale of crustal mobility, powered by the Earth's moving plates. To understand this story, we need to look at how the Earth creates and destroys its ocean floor.

Pillow basalt (also called pillow lava) forms from lava eruptions on the deep seabed at mid-ocean ridges—broad undersea mountain belts that wrap around the planet like the seams on a baseball. Deep rift valleys run down the centers of these ridges. The ocean floor slowly splits at these rifts, and lava wells up into the gap to congeal like blood in a wound. The lava squeezes out as toothpaste-like gobs, glowing red for an instant before the cold seawater quenches it into mounds about the size of a bed pillow. As the seawater circulates through cracks in the hot rock, chemical changes trigger the growth of chlorite minerals, which tint the black basalt green.

Take a submarine down to the central rift valleys of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge or the East Pacific Rise, and you can see the seabed splitting and the lava erupting and forming pillows. Cruise along the deep seabed in either direction away from these central rifts, and the pillows become more deeply buried in seabed muck. That muck—technically known as ooze—is made mostly of microscopic plankton remains. Geologists, by puncturing the deep seabed with thousands of drill holes, have learned two important things about this ooze and the pillow basalt underneath it. First, drill down through enough ooze and you eventually hit pillow basalt. Second, the farther you go from a mid-ocean ridge, the thicker the ooze and the older the pillow basalt beneath it.

These facts tuck neatly into the concept of seafloor spreading—the Earth's system for manufacturing new ocean floor (figure 1.3). After lava erupts at a mid-ocean ridge to form pillows, it makes room for new lava by spreading away in opposite directions, like two oppositely moving conveyor belts. As the seabed spreads from the ridge, planktonic ooze slowly buries the pillows under ever-thicker layers. The world's mid-ocean ridges spread in this conveyor belt-like manner about two inches per year, on average. That's a plodding pace in human time, to be sure—but so what? Compared to geologic time, human time is virtually insignificant, like a couple of still-frames in a feature-length movie. Take two inches per year over the entire 40,000-mile-long mid-ocean ridge system and watch what happens when geologic time takes over. In 2.4 million years, the Earth will manufacture an area of ocean floor equal to that of the lower forty-eight U.S. states. And in 158 million years—a span less than 4 percent of the age of the Earth—that pace of seafloor spreading will create an area of ocean floor equal to the surface area of the entire planet!

What happens to all of this newly minted ocean floor? With the seabed constantly splitting and growing from its mid-ocean ridges, you might expect the planet to be swelling like a balloon. But it's not, because the ocean floor is destroyed apace with creation. This happens at ocean trenches—great troughs where the ocean floor bends down beneath a neighboring plate to plunge into the Earth's hot interior (figure 1.3). This process—called subduction—consumes the ocean floor almost as fast as seafloor spreading produces it.


Subduction, it turns out, doesn't eat up every square foot of ocean floor churned out by seafloor spreading. There is a small—but crucial—imbalance between the creation of the ocean floor and its destruction. That imbalance has created California. It explains (among other things) how pillow basalt has ended up at Point Bonita in the Golden Gate.

As the seafloor slides into an ocean trench, the edge of the adjacent plate can act like a plow blade, scraping off slivers of seafloor rock. Anything sticking up from the seafloor—submarine plateaus, seamounts, or even entire islands—can get scraped off as well. If a continent tries to follow the ocean floor into a trench, it won't go far. Instead, after going a little way down the trench, the edge of the continent may lever a piece of ocean floor up out of the sea like a pig wedging a truffle out of the ground. The astonishing result—played out over the scope of geologic time—is that continents grow bigger as pieces of oceanic rock collect against their edges. Stand anywhere in western Mexico, California, Oregon, Washington, British Columbia, or Alaska, and you stand—more often than not—on pieces of former ocean floor that have been scraped or lifted off the deep seabed and marooned on North America's western edge, mostly during the last 200 million years (figure 1.4).

The reason this has happened comes down to North America's long history of westward migration, combined with the eastward migration of pieces of old ocean floor that have slid underneath or collided with North America's western edge. Two hundred and fifty million years ago, our continent was firmly stuck to Eurasia and Africa as part of the supercontinent Pangaea. But about 200 million years ago, North America began to tear away and head west. New ocean floor created by seafloor spreading in the young, growing Atlantic had to be balanced by destruction of ocean floor elsewhere. That happened as the continent overrode or collided with multiple pieces of ancient Pacific Ocean floor. Much of this old seabed went under the continent, but several million square miles of it glommed onto the continent's western edge, adding the new geologic real estate shown in figure 1.4.

Now we can circle back to Point Bonita and shine the light of these concepts on the pillow basalt there. More than one hundred million years ago, the pillows formed part of the seabed of the Farallon Plate—a big oceanic plate that once plunged under North America's western edge. Instead of sliding down the trench with the rest of the plate, the pillow basalts that we now see at Point Bonita sheared off next to the trench to join what is called an accretionary wedge. Jammed against the continent, the rocks of the accretionary wedge became new land for California (figures 1.5 and 1.6).

The pillow basalt at Point Bonita is just the tip of this accretionary rock iceberg. Pillow basalts crop out throughout the Marin Headlands above Point Bonita, on the Twin Peaks near downtown San Francisco, high above sea level on Mount Diablo east of Berkeley, and in dozens of other places throughout the Bay Area. What city but San Francisco could feature a tourist guidebook called A Streetcar to Subduction, which will take you to outcrops of these deep-sea rocks by way of public transportation? Franciscan Complex is the name given to this collection of deep-sea rocks that collected in the accretionary wedge above the Farallon Plate. You'd be hard-pressed to find a more mixed-up, fault-shattered mess of rock on Earth. The Franciscan Complex is what happens when subduction takes quadrillions of tons of old seabed and jams it against the edge of a continent.

* * *

Above Point Bonita and its pillow basalts, the land rises steeply in mottled shades of coastal scrub to form the north shoulder of the Golden Gate. These are the Marin Headlands, a piece of near-wild California, where raptors, bobcats, mountain lions, and coyotes far outnumber people. Grim concrete relicts of military readiness dot the headlands: gun batteries from two world wars and a surface-to-air missile battery from the Cold War. When active, the gun batteries could fire 2100-pound shells as far as the Farallon Islands. Most of the old gun batteries on the Marin Headlands sink their foundations not into pillow basalt, but chert—another abyssal import scraped off the Farallon Plate.

After pillow basalts form and spread away from mid-ocean ridges, they catch a steady rain of planktonic debris (ooze) from the waters above. Many plankton cells contain lacy microscopic skeletons made of calcium carbonate or silica. The calcium carbonate skeletons often dissolve under the pressure and cold of the abyss, but the silica ones usually don't. Instead, they settle like fine snow onto the pillowed seabed, where they eventually harden into chert—a siliceous rock that breaks in scalloped curves like thick glass. Chipped by skilled hands, chert becomes arrowheads and spear points. (Flint is chert in archeological clothing.) When subduction scrapes pillows off the seabed, the chert above the pillows comes along for the ride. The chert layers often scrunch into fantastic contortions as they mash into the accretionary wedge (figure 1.7).

The chert in the Marin Headlands comes mostly from microscope creatures called radiolarians, a common form of siliceous plankton. The radiolarians date from the Early Jurassic to Middle Cretaceous time periods, meaning from about 200 million to 100 million years ago. (See the geological time scale at the front of the book.) Most of the radiolarians found in the Marin Headlands are of tropical species that lived in the warm equatorial waters of the ancient Pacific. Think about what this means—the chert that we now see in the Marin Headlands must have traveled all the way from the equator, some 2,000 to 3,000 miles, before subduction added it to California's doorstep. Most of California is built of equally well-traveled rocks.

My favorite stop in the Marin Headlands is Battery 129, an abandoned gun battery perched on bluffs high above the Golden Gate. Battery 129 draws tourists like bears to honey; the view of the Golden Gate Bridge, and of downtown San Francisco beyond, is the best that can be had outside of a helicopter ride. But forget the view, I tell anyone who will listen. A much more dramatic sight lies in the nearby road cut. If you go to the Marin Headlands, don't miss the chance to put your nose on the road cut by Battery 129 (figure 1.8). The cut exposes a cross section of the Jurassic ocean floor, where layers of brick-red chert can be seen lying directly on top of pillow basalt. Lay your hands on these rocks and time shifts to 160 million years ago, to the floor of the tropical Pacific, three miles below sea level and more than 2,000 miles from California. The weathered and crumbling pillows under your hands are now fresh lava, squeezing like incandescent toothpaste out of the splitting seabed, glowing for an instant before the cold water quenches them to stone. Move upward now and lay your hands on the chert. Now billions of microscopic radiolarians are settling through the dark waters to bury the seabed in a rising tide of siliceous ooze. All the while, the conveyor belt-like movement of the Farallon Plate is carrying the seabed northeast, toward the trench that once lay off California's coast. There, the seabed bends like a down escalator into the trench. The chert and pillow basalt seemed destined to disappear into the bowels of the planet—but they don't. Instead, they shear off to join the great accretionary wedge above the Farallon Plate. Crowded and squeezed upward by other rock wedging in from behind, they rise slowly out of the sea. And so, here they are today, remarkably unmangled considering their incredible journey. You can see and touch all of this history in this one outcrop—one that captures a span of time nearly one million times longer than the history of the United States.


Excerpted from Rough-Hewn Land by Keith Heyer Meldahl. Copyright © 2011 the Regents of the University of California. Excerpted by permission of UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Table of Contents


1. Golden Gate
2. Mother Lode
3. Rivers of Gold
4. A Traverse across the Range of Light
5. Where Is the Edge of the North American Plate?

6. Where Rivers Die
7. The Growing Pains of Mountains
8. Wealth and Magma
9. Water and Salt
10. Evolution’s Big Bang

11. Range- Roving Rivers
12. Up from the Basement
13. At the Frontier

Appendix I: Deep Time: Fathoming the Rock Record
Appendix II: Seeing for Yourself

Figure Sources and Credits

What People are Saying About This

From the Publisher

"The writing is so conversational that it's hard to believe this is science. . . . Meldahl has captured the wonder, as well as the facts that produced it [the geologic world of the American West] in this vaguely unsettling (so much activity in what we depend on to be still and solid) and enlightening book."—The Atlantic

"Informative and highly readable, "Rough-Hewn Land" belongs on the shelf of any Westerner curious about how that stunning view through the windshield came to be."—Los Angeles Times Book Review

"An absorbing book. . . . A good introduction to the geology of the region."—The Guardian

"A unique and intriguing book that perfectly brings together an infectious passion for earth science, a down-to-earth writing style, and deep thinking about how geology affects the human experience."—Washington
Ind Rev of Bks

"A magnificent volume. . . . The broad coverage has something for every geologist, as well as anyone with an interest in the geography, geology, history, and development of the western United States."—Geological Journal

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

Rough-Hewn Land 3.5 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 2 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
A well done, up to date, detailed presentation of the geology of the USA west of the Rocky Mts. A geology book for the general reader, but some geologic knowledge as background would be helpful. One only wishes all science were so well presented!
Anonymous More than 1 year ago