ISBN-10:
0300163681
ISBN-13:
9780300163681
Pub. Date:
04/20/2010
Publisher:
Yale University Press
Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia / Edition 2

Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia / Edition 2

by Ahmed Rashid

Paperback

View All Available Formats & Editions
Current price is , Original price is $22.0. You
Select a Purchase Option (2)
  • purchase options
    $17.20 $22.00 Save 22% Current price is $17.2, Original price is $22. You Save 22%.
  • purchase options

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780300163681
Publisher: Yale University Press
Publication date: 04/20/2010
Edition description: 2
Pages: 344
Sales rank: 468,154
Product dimensions: 5.50(w) x 8.20(h) x 1.10(d)

About the Author


Called “Pakistan’s best and bravest reporter” by Christopher Hitchens in Vanity Fair, Ahmed Rashid was a correspondent for the Far Eastern Economic Review for more than twenty years, covering Pakistan, Afghanistan, and central Asia. He now writes for BBC Online, the Washington Post, El Mundo, the International Herald Tribune, the New York Review of Books, and other foreign and Pakistani newspapers. He has been covering the wars in Afghanistan, as well as the wars in Pakistan and Tajikistan, since 1979. He is the author of Descent into Chaos and Jihad.

Read an Excerpt

Excerpt from
Chapter 1:

Kandahar 1994: The Origins of The Taliban

The Taliban's wounds are a constant reminder of 20 years of war, which has killed over 1.5 million people and devastated the country. The Soviet Union poured some US$5 billion a year into Afghanistan to subdue the Mujaheddin or a total of US$45 billion — and they lost. The US committed some four to five billion dollars between 1980 and 1992 in aid to the Mujaheddin. US funds were matched by Saudi Arabia and together with support from other European and Islamic countries, the Mujaheddin received a total of over US$10 billion. Most of this aid was in the form of lethal modern weaponry given to a simple agricultural people who used it with devastating results.

The war wounds of the Taliban leaders also reflect the bloody and brutal style of war that took place in and around Kandahar in the 1980s. The Durrani Pashtuns who inhabit the south and Kandahar received far less aid through the CIA and Western aid pipeline which armed, financed and provided logistics such as medical facilities to the Mujaheddin, as compared to the Ghilzai Pashtuns in the east of the country and around Kabul. The aid was distributed by Pakistan's Interservices Intelligence (ISI), who tended to treat Kandahar as a backwater and the Durranis with suspicion. As a consequence the nearest medical facilities for a wounded Kandahari Mujaheddin was a bone-shaking two-day camel ride to Quetta across the border in Pakistan. Even today first-aid amongst the Taliban is rare, doctors are all too few and surgeons on the front line non-existent. Virtually the only medical practitioners in the country are the hospitals of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).

By chance I was in Kandahar in December 1979 and watched the first Soviet tanks roll in. Teenage Soviet soldiers had driven for two days from the Soviet Republic of Turkmenistan in Central Asia to Herat and then on to Kandahar along a metalled highway that the Soviets had themselves built in the 1960s. Many of the soldiers were of Central Asian origin. They got out of their tanks, dusted off their uniforms and ambled across to the nearest stall for a cup of sugarless green tea — a staple part of the diet in both Afghanistan and Central Asia. The Afghans in the bazaar just stood and stared. On 27 December Soviet Spetsnatz or Special Forces had stormed the palace of President Hafizullah Amin in Kabul, killed him, occupied Kabul and appointed Babrak Karmal as President.

When the resistance began around Kandahar it was based on the tribal network of the Durranis. In Kandahar the struggle against the Soviets was a tribal jihad led by clan chiefs and ulema (senior religious scholars) rather than an ideological jihad led by Islamicists. In Peshawar there were seven Mujaheddin parties which were recognised by Pakistan and received a share of aid from the CIA pipeline. Significantly none of the seven parties were led by Durrani Pashtuns. In Kandahar all seven parties had a following, but the most popular parties in the south were those based on tribal ties such as the Harakat-e-Inquilab Islami (Movement of the Islamic Revolution) led by Maulvi Mohammed Nabi Mohammedi and another Hizb-e-Islami (Party of Islam) led by Maulvi Younis Khalis. Before the war both leaders were well known in the Pashtun belt and ran their own madrassas or religious schools.

For commanders in the south party loyalty depended on which Peshawar leader would provide money and arms. Mullah Omar joined Khalis's Hizb-e-Islami while Mullah Hassan joined Harakat. 'I knew Omar extremely well but we were fighting on different fronts and in different groups but sometimes we fought together,' said Hassan. Also popular was the National Islamic Front led by Pir Sayed Ahmad Gailani, who advocated the return of the Durrani ex-King Zahir Shah to lead the Afghan resistance — a move that was strongly opposed by Pakistan and the USA. The ex-King was living in Rome and continued to be a popular figure amongst the Kandaharis, who hoped that his return would reassert the leadership role of the Durrani tribes.

The contradictions within the Pashtun Mujaheddin leadership were to weaken the Pashtuns as the war progressed. The ulema valued the historical ideals of early Islamic history and rarely challenged traditional Afghan tribal structures like the Jirga. They were also much more accommodating towards the ethnic minorities. The Islamicists denigrated the tribal structure and pursued a radical political ideology in order to bring about an Islamic revolution in Afghanistan. They were exclusivists which made the minorities suspicious of them.

Thus Harakat had no coherent party structure and was just a loose alliance between commanders and tribal chiefs, many of whom had just a rudimentary madrassa education. On the other hand Gulbuddin Hikmetyar's Hizb-e-Islami built a secretive, highly centralized, political organization whose cadres were drawn from educated urban Pashtuns. Prior to the war the Islamicists barely had a base in Afghan society, but with money and arms from the CIA pipeline and support from Pakistan, they built one and wielded tremendous clout. The traditionalists and the Islamicists fought each other mercilessly so that by 1994, the traditional leadership in Kandahar had virtually been eliminated, leaving the field free for the new wave of even more extreme Islamicists — the Taliban.

The battle for Kandahar was also determined by its own particular history. Kandahar is Afghanistan's second largest city with a 1979 pre-war population of about 250,000 and twice that today. The old city has been inhabited since 500 BC, but just 35 miles away lies Mundigak, a Bronze-Age village settled around 3,000 BC, which was once part of the Indus Valley civilization. Kandaharis have always been great traders as the city was located at the intersection of ancient trade routes — eastwards across the Bolan Pass to Sind, the Arabian Sea and India and westwards to Herat and Iran. The city was the main crossing point for trade, arts and crafts between Iran and India and the city's numerous bazaars have been famous for centuries.

The new city has changed little from that laid out in grand proportions in 1761 by Ahmad Shah Durrani, the founder of the Durrani dynasty. The fact that the Durranis from Kandahar were to create the Afghan state and rule it for 300 years gave the Kandaharis a special status amongst the Pashtuns. As a concession to their home base, Kabul's kings absolved the Kandaharis from providing manpower for the army. Ahmad Shah's mausoleum dominates the central bazaar and thousands of Afghans still come here to pray and pay their respects to the founder of the nation.

Next to his tomb is the shrine of the Cloak of the Prophet Mohammed — one of the holiest places of worship in Afghanistan. The Cloak has been shown only on rare occasions such as when King Amanullah tried to rally the tribes in 1929 and when a cholera epidemic hit the city in 1935. But in 1996 in order to legitimise his role as leader and one ordained by God to lead the Afghan people, Mullah Omar took out the cloak and showed it to a large crowd of Taliban who then named him Amir-ul Momineen or Leader of the Faithful.

However, Kandahar's fame across the region rests on its fruit orchards. Kandahar is an oasis town set in the desert and the summer heat is devastating, but around the city are lush, green fields and shady orchards producing grapes, melons, mulberries, figs, peaches and pomegranates which were famous throughout India and Iran. Kandahar's pomegranates decorated Persian manuscripts written one thousand years ago and were served at the table of the British Governor General of India in Delhi during the last century. The city's truck transporters, who were to give major financial support to the Taliban in their drive to conquer the country, began their trade in the last century when they carried Kandahar's fruit as far as Delhi and Calcutta.

The orchards were watered by a complex and well-maintained irrigation system until the war, when both the Soviets and the Mujaheddin so heavily mined the fields that the rural population fled to Pakistan and the orchards were abandoned. Kandahar remains one of the most heavily mined cities in the world. In an otherwise flat landscape, the orchards and water channels provided cover for the Mujaheddin who quickly took control of the countryside, isolating the Soviet garrison in the city. The Soviets retaliated by cutting down thousands of trees and smashing the irrigation system. When the refugees were to return to their devastated orchards after 1990, they were to grow opium poppies for a livelihood, creating a major source of income for the Taliban.

With the Soviet withdrawal in 1989 there followed a long struggle against the regime of President Najibullah until he was overthrown in 1992 and the Mujaheddin captured Kabul. Much of Afghanistan's subsequent civil war was to be determined by the fact that Kabul fell, not to the well-armed and bickering Pashtun parties based in Peshawar, but to the better organized and more united Tajik forces of Burhanuddin Rabbani and his military commander Ahmad Shah Masud and to the Uzbek forces from the north under General Rashid Dostum. It was a devastating psychological blow because for the first time in 300 years the Pashtuns had lost control of the capital. An internal civil war began almost immediately as Hikmetyar attempted to rally the Pashtuns and laid siege to Kabul, shelling it mercilessly.

Afghanistan was in a state of virtual disintegration just before the Taliban emerged at the end of 1994. The country was divided into warlord fiefdoms and all the warlords had fought, switched sides and fought again in a bewildering array of alliances, betrayals and bloodshed. The predominantly Tajik government of President Burhanuddin Rabbani controlled Kabul, its environs and the north-east of the country, while three provinces in the west centring on Herat were controlled by Ismael Khan. In the east on the Pakistan border three Pashtun provinces were under the independent control of a council or Shura (Council) of Mujaheddin commanders based in Jalalabad. A small region to the south and east of Kabul was controlled by Gulbuddin Hikmetyar.

In the north the Uzbek warlord General Rashid Dostum held sway over six provinces and in January 1994 he had abandoned his alliance with the Rabbani government and joined with Hikmetyar to attack Kabul. In central Afghanistan the Hazaras controlled the province of Bamiyan. Southern Afghanistan and Kandahar were divided up amongst dozens of petty ex-Mujaheddin warlords and bandits who plundered the population at will. With the tribal structure and the economy in tatters, no consensus on a Pashtun leadership and Pakistan's unwillingness to provide military aid to the Durranis as they did to Hikmetyar, the Pashtuns in the south were at war with each other.

International aid agencies were fearful of even working in Kandahar as the city itself was divided by warring groups. Their leaders sold off everything to Pakistani traders to make money, stripping down telephone wires and poles, cutting trees, selling off factories, machinery and even road rollers to scrap merchants. The warlords seized homes and farms, threw out their occupants and handed them over to their supporters. The commanders abused the population at will, kidnapping young girls and boys for their sexual pleasure, robbing merchants in the bazaars and fighting and brawling in the streets. Instead of refugees returning from Pakistan, a fresh wave of refugees began to leave Kandahar for Quetta.

For the powerful mafia of truck transporters based in Quetta and Kandahar, it was an intolerable situation for business. In 1993 I travelled the short 130 miles by road from Quetta to Kandahar and we were stopped by at least 20 different groups, who had put chains across the road and demanded a toll for free passage. The transport mafia who were trying to open up routes to smuggle goods between Quetta and Iran and the newly independent state of Turkmenistan, found it impossible to do business.

For those Mujaheddin who had fought the Najibullah regime and had then gone home or to continue their studies at madrassas in Quetta and Kandahar, the situation was particularly galling. 'We all knew each other — Mullahs Omar, Ghaus, Mohammed Rabbani (no relation to President Rabbani) and myself — because we were all originally from Urozgan province and had fought together,' said Mulla Hassan. 'I moved back and forth from Quetta and attended madrassas there, but whenever we got together we would discuss the terrible plight of our people living under these bandits. We were people of the same opinions and we got on with each other very well, so it was easy to come to a decision to do something,' he added.

Mullah Mohammed Ghaus, the one-eyed Foreign Minister of the Taliban said much the same. 'We would sit for a long time to discuss how to change the terrible situation. Before we started we had only vague ideas what to do and we thought we would fail, but we believed we were working with Allah as His pupils. We have got so far because Allah has helped us,' said Ghaus. Other groups of Mujaheddin in the south were also discussing the same problems. 'Many people were searching for a solution. I was from Kalat in Zabul province (85 miles north of Kandahar) and had joined a madrassa, but the situation was so bad that we were distracted from our studies and with a group of friends we spent all our time discussing what we should do and what needed to be done,' said Mullah Mohammed Abbas, who was to become the Minister of Public Health in Kabul. 'The old Mujaheddin leadership had utterly failed to bring peace. So I went with a group of friends to Herat to attend the Shura called by Ismael Khan, but it failed to come up with a solution and things were getting worse. So we came to Kandahar to talk with Mullah Omar and joined him,' Abbas added.

After much discussion these divergent but deeply concerned groups chalked out an agenda which still remains the Taliban's declared aims — restore peace, disarm the population, enforce Sharia law and defend the integrity and Islamic character of Afghanistan. As most of them were part-time or full-time students at madrassas, the name they chose for themselves was natural. A talib is an Islamic student, one who seeks knowledge compared to the mullah who is one who gives knowledge. By choosing such a name the Taliban (plural of Talib) distanced themselves from the party politics of the Mujaheddin and signalled that they were a movement for cleansing society rather than a party trying to grab power.

All those who gathered around Omar were the children of the jihad but deeply disillusioned with the factionalism and criminal activities of the once idealised Mujaheddin leadership. They saw themselves as the cleansers and purifiers of a guerrilla war gone astray, a social system gone wrong and an Islamic way of life that had been compromised by corruption and excess. Many of them had been born in Pakistani refugee camps, educated in Pakistani madrassas and had learnt their fighting skills from Mujaheddin parties based in Pakistan. As such the younger Taliban barely knew their own country or history, but from their madrassas they learnt about the ideal Islamic society created by the Prophet Mohammed 1,400 years ago and this is what they wanted to emulate.

Some Taliban say Omar was chosen as their leader not for his political or military ability, but for his piety and his unswerving belief in Islam. Others say he was chosen by God. 'We selected Mullah Omar to lead this movement. He was the first amongst equals and we gave him the power to lead us and he has given us the power and authority to deal with people's problems,' said Mullah Hassan. Omar himself gave a simple explanation to Pakistani journalist Rahimullah Yousufzai. 'We took up arms to achieve the aims of the Afghan jihad and save our people from further suffering at the hands of the so-called Mujaheddin. We had complete faith in God Almighty. We never forgot that. He can bless us with victory or plunge us into defeat,' said Omar.

No leader in the world today is surrounded by as much secrecy and mystery as Mullah Mohammed Omar. Aged 39, he has never been photographed or met with Western diplomats and journalists. His first meeting with a UN diplomat was in October 1998, four years after the Taliban emerged, when he met with the UN Special Representative for Afghanistan Lakhdar Brahimi, because the Taliban were faced with a possibly devastating attack by Iran. Omar lives in Kandahar and has visited the capital Kabul twice and only then very briefly. Putting together the bare facts of his life has become a full-time job for most Afghans and foreign diplomats.

Omar was born sometime around 1959 in Nodeh village near Kandahar to a family of poor, landless peasants who were members of the Hotak tribe, the Ghilzai branch of Pashtuns. The Hotaki chief Mir Wais, had captured Isfahan in Iran in 1721 and established the first Ghilzai Afghan empire in Iran only to be quickly replaced by Ahmad Shah Durrani. Omar's tribal and social status was non-existent and notables from Kandahar say they had never heard of his family. During the 1980s jihad his family moved to Tarinkot in Urozgan province — one of the most backward and inaccessible regions of the country where Soviet troops rarely penetrated. His father died while he was a young man and the task of fending for his mother and extended family fell upon him.

Looking for a job, he moved to Singesar village in the Mewand district of Kandahar province, where he became the village mullah and opened a small madrassa. His own studies in madrassas in Kandahar were interrupted twice, first by the Soviet invasion and then by the creation of the Taliban. Omar joined Khalis's Hizb-e-Islami and fought under commander Nek Mohammed against the Najibullah regime between 1989 and 1992. He was wounded four times, once in the right eye which is now permanently blinded.

Despite the success of the Taliban, Singesar is still like any other Pashtun village. Mud-brick homes plastered with more mud and straw are built behind high compound walls — a traditional defensive feature of Pashtun homes. Narrow, dusty alleyways, which turn into mud baths when it rains, connect village homes. Omar's madrassa is still functioning — a small mud hut with a dirt floor and mattresses strewn across it for the boys to sleep on. Omar has three wives, who continue living in the village and are heavily veiled. While his first and third wives are from Urozgan, his teenage second wife Guljana, whom he married in 1995, is from Singesar. He has a total of five children who are studying in his madrassa.

A tall, well-built man with a long, black beard and a black turban, Omar has a dry sense of humour and a sarcastic wit. He remains extremely shy of outsiders, particularly foreigners, but he is accessible to the Taliban. When the movement started he would offer his Friday prayers at the main mosque in Kandahar and mix with the people, but subsequently he has become much more of a recluse, rarely venturing outside Kandahar's administrative mansion where he lives. He now visits his village infrequently and when he does he is always accompanied by dozens of bodyguards in a convoy of deluxe Japanese jeepsters with darkened windows.

Omar speaks very little in Shura meetings, listening to other points of view. His shyness makes him a poor public speaker and despite the mythology that now surrounds him, he has little charismatic appeal. All day he conducts business from a small office in the mansion. At first he used to sit on the cement floor alongside visiting Taliban, but he now sits on a bed while others sit on the floor — a move that emphasises his status as leader. He has several secretaries who take notes from his conversations with commanders, ordinary soldiers, ulema and plaintiffs and there is always the crackle of wireless sets as commanders around the country communicate with him.

Business consists of lengthy debate and discussions which end with the issuing of 'chits' or scraps of paper on which are written instructions allowing commanders to make an attack, ordering a Taliban governor to help out a plaintiff or a message to UN mediators. Formal communications to foreign embassies in Islamabad were frequently dictated by Pakistani advisers.

In the early days of the movement I collected numerous chits written on cigarette boxes or wrapping paper, allowing me to travel from city to city. Now more regular paper pads are used. Beside Omar is a tin trunk from which he dishes out wads of Afghani notes to commanders and plaintiffs in need. As success came, another tin trunk was added — this one containing US dollars. These tin trunks are the treasury of the Taliban movement.

In important meetings, Mullah Wakil Ahmad, Omar's trusted confidant and official spokesman is usually beside him. Wakil, a young madrassa student from the Kakar tribe who studied under Omar, started out as his companion, driver, food taster, translator and note-taker. He quickly progressed to higher things such as communicating with visiting foreign diplomats and aid agency officials, travelling to meet Taliban commanders and meeting with Pakistani officials. As Omar's spokesman he is the Taliban's main contact with the foreign press as well as its chastizer, when he feels that journalists have criticized the Taliban too harshly. Wakil acts as Omar's ears and eyes and is also his doorkeeper. No important Afghan can reach Omar without first going through Wakil.

There is now an entire factory of myths and stories to explain how Omar mobilized a small group of Taliban against the rapacious Kandahar warlords. The most credible story, told repeatedly, is that in the spring of 1994 Singesar neighbours came to tell him that a commander had abducted two teenage girls, their heads had been shaved and they had been taken to a military camp and repeatedly raped. Omar enlisted some 30 Talibs who had only 16 rifles between them and attacked the base, freeing the girls and hanging the commander from the barrel of a tank. They captured quantities of arms and ammunition. 'We were fighting against Muslims who had gone wrong. How could we remain quiet when we could see crimes being committed against women and the poor?' Omar said later.

A few months later two commanders confronted each other in Kandahar, in a dispute over a young boy whom both men wanted to sodomise. In the fight that followed civilians were killed. Omar's group freed the boy and public appeals started coming in for the Taliban to help out in other local disputes. Omar had emerged as a Robin Hood figure, helping the poor against the rapacious commanders. His prestige grew because he asked for no reward or credit from those he helped, only demanding that they follow him to set up a just Islamic system.

At the same time Omar's emissaries were gauging the mood of other commanders. His colleagues visited Herat to meet with Ismael Khan and in September Mulla Mohammed Rabbani, a founding member of the Taliban, visited Kabul and held talks with President Rabbani. The isolated Kabul government wished to support any new Pashtun force that would oppose Hikmetyar, who was still shelling Kabul, and Rabbani promised to help the Taliban with funds if they opposed Hikmetyar.

However the Taliban's closest links were with Pakistan where many of them had grown up and studied in madrassas run by the mercurial Maulana Fazlur Rehman and his Jamiat-e-Ulema Islam (JUI), a fundamentalist party which had considerable support amongst the Pashtuns in Baluchistan and the North West Frontier Province (NWFP). More significantly Maulana Rehman was now a political ally of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto and he had access to the government, the army and the ISI to whom he described this newly emerging force.

Pakistan's Afghan policy was in the doldrums. After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, successive Pakistani governments were desperately keen to open up direct land routes for trade with the Central Asian Republics (CARs). The major hindrance was the continuing civil war in Afghanistan, through which any route passed. Pakistan's policy-makers were thus faced with a strategic dilemma. Either Pakistan could carry on backing Hikmetyar in a bid to bring a Pashtun group to power in Kabul which would be Pakistan-friendly, or it could change direction and urge for a power-sharing agreement between all the Afghan factions at whatever the price for the Pashtuns, so that a stable government could open the roads to Central Asia.

The Pakistani military was convinced that other ethnic groups would not do their bidding and continued to back Hikmetyar. Some 20 per cent of the Pakistan army was made up of Pakistani Pashtuns and the pro-Pashtun and Islamic fundamentalist lobby within the ISI and the military remained determined to achieve a Pashtun victory in Afghanistan. However, by 1994 Hikmetyar had clearly failed, losing ground militarily while his extremism divided the Pashtuns, the majority of whom loathed him. Pakistan was getting tired of backing a loser and was looking around for other potential Pashtun proxies.

When Benazir Bhutto was elected as Prime Minister in 1993, she was keen to open a route to Central Asia. The shortest route was from Peshawar to Kabul, across the Hindu Kush mountains to Mazar-e-Sharif and then to Tirmez and Tashkent in Uzbekistan, but this route was closed due to the fighting around Kabul. A new proposal emerged, backed strongly by the frustrated Pakistani transport and smuggling mafia, the JUI and Pashtun military and political officials. Instead of the northern route the way could be cleared from Quetta to Kandahar, Herat and on to Ashkhabad, the capital of Turkmenistan. There was no fighting in the south, only dozens of commanders who would have to be adequately bribed before they agreed to open the chains...

Table of Contents

Preface and Acknowledgementsvii
Mapsxiii
Introduction: Afghanistan's Holy Warriors1
Part 1History of the Taliban Movement
Chapter 1Kandahar 1994: The Origins of the Taliban17
Chapter 2Herat 1995: God's Invincible Soldiers31
Chapter 3Kabul 1996: Commander of the Faithful41
Chapter 4Mazar-e-Sharif 1997: Massacre in the North55
Chapter 5Bamiyan 1998-99: The Never-Ending War67
Part 2Islam and the Taliban
Chapter 6Challenging Islam: The New-Style Fundamentalism of the Taliban82
Chapter 7Secret Society: The Taliban's Political and Military Organization95
Chapter 8A Vanished Gender: Women, Children and Taliban Culture105
Chapter 9High on Heroin: Drugs and the Taliban Economy117
Chapter 10Global Jihad: The Arab-Afghans and Osama Bin Laden128
Part 3The New Great Game
Chapter 11Dictators and Oil Barons: The Taliban and Central Asia, Russia, Turkey and Israel143
Chapter 12Romancing the Taliban 1: The Battle for Pipelines 1994-96157
Chapter 13Romancing the Taliban 2: The Battle for Pipelines 1997-99--The USA and the Taliban170
Chapter 14Master or Victim: Pakistan's Afghan War183
Chapter 15Shia and Sunni: Iran and Saudi Arabia196
Chapter 16Conclusion: The Future of Afghanistan207
Appendices217
Notes248
Index266

What People are Saying About This

Fred Halliday

This is an impressive analysis of the Taliban movement in Afghanistan, of its background and impact on our country, and the wider regional and political implications of the Taliban advent power….
—(Fred Halliday, Professor of International Relations of The London School of Economics author of Revolution and World Politics: The Rise and Fall of Sixth Great Power)

Barnett R. Rubin

Rashid combines close journalistic experience with the Taliban and long-term knowledge of Afghanistan in this work of great depth and understanding.
—(Barnett Rubin author of The Segmentation of Afghanistan and The Search for Peace in Afghanistan)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia, Second Edition 4.2 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 27 reviews.
JayHay More than 1 year ago
This book offers a rare look inside the groups and personalities of Afghanistan's influential diaspora. While the Taliban is the focus of the book I enjoy Rashid's inclusion of all the groups that have shaped Afghanistan's recent history. The Pashtun tribes are the obvious focus of most Afghan books but he does an excellent job of integrating the Uzebk, Tajik and Hazara perspectives in Afghan politics. The vignettes of the brutality with which not just the Taliban but the other ethnic groups conducted operations against each other gives us the perspective that some militants are irreconcilable. But Rashid leaves open the possibility that the majority of the tribesmen may be amenable to a tepid peace. His exploration of all of the ethnic groups reveals an entrenched sense perpetual conflict, I think the challenge is translating their tendency for violent conflict into non-violent conflict. Overall a very well-written book; the second edition is an added treat with the inclusion of his perspectives on new developments. I would definitely recommend this book for anyone interested in historical Afghan tribal relations, specifically in the years after the Soviet withdrawal up until 11 September 2001.
BenderHeel More than 1 year ago
I just finished Ahmed Rashid's book and was blown away by it. Excellent writing with a thorough look into the world of the Taliban and the various politics and relationships involved in the Taliban's rise to power. Some of the information will make you cringe when reading it with the hindsight of the events that have unfolded in the region since Rashid wrote this in 1999, although it is still as influential today -- perhaps even moreso -- as the United States finally puts a full-court effort into the region to stablize it. Also, I'm not sure how any of the past reviewers can critize the book for being difficult to read because of the foreign names and locales, as obviously that kind of information cannot be held against the author. I thought that the writing was great and flowed like a good narrative story. Further, when Rashid referred to the characters or places, he would provide the context so that the reader can recall who/what he is referring to. Finally, there are some very interesting and insightful appendices cataloging the leadership of the Taliban and just how uneducated and ignorant they are/were, as well as some of the laws that they passed.
Guest More than 1 year ago
I chose this book after the Sept. 11 attacks to do as my nonfiction book report. The book was useful because it gave me the whole understanding of the enviroment in which the Taliban came to power. Some parts are a little bit confusing because there are so many places, people and tribes. I would recommend this book for book reports or everyday reading.
niafong More than 1 year ago
Ahmad Rashid masterful book on the Taliban has been totally correct, as his brilliant analysis of the "New Great Game" has showed remarkable accuracy as Russia and Iran and Qatar are now a new OPEC to compete against the traditional Arabic-dominated Opec and this triumvirate is becoming a power to reckon with. Also, China, another growing power is showing interest is watching the development of the Caucus Central Asian Republics and teamed up with many of them to become allies in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, and America as usual is showing its toughness and dynamism and almost became smitten with the Taliban, after all they are natural ideological allies... both are highly nationalistic, religious, and conservative and influential. However, America took up the friendship of Turkey instead. India, an independent power, still relies much on Russia, but less and less every year and America is showed a friendship with Pakistan to offset the special relationship between Russia and India. Then there is the issue of radical Islam, a separate power unto itself. And Afghanistan has still shown that all these powers have interest by all these powers.
Guest More than 1 year ago
This book reveals what this organization is all about --- from activities planning to membership hierarchy. The descriptions throughout the book detail what we have seen in news reports concerning the Taliban. However, while the media has failed to disclose the enormity of the horrendous nature of the Taliban, the author tells all. From senseless executions to ridiculous business demands, it¿s all here. The book is a somewhat difficult read, due to the many references to Middle Eastern names and terms, etc., but the information provided is well worth it.
Guest More than 1 year ago
I am currently deployed conducting combat operations in support of Operation Enduring Freedom. I bought this book in order to gain insight into the the history of Afghanistan and how the Taliban came to power. This book has provided myself, and numerous personnel within my unit, with a better understanding of the 'enemy.' History tends to repeat itself and Rashid's unbiased account of the group's history has aided us in developing a better understanding of the current situation on the battlefield. Would recommend this book to all warfighters.
Guest More than 1 year ago
In an era where mainstream media is becoming increasingly entertainment-based, it's encouraging to see a book that seeks not to entertain, but to educate. That's not to say, however, that the book is boring; it is thorougly engaging and will give the reader plenty to ponder. Every American should read this book to gain a better understanding of what is occurring in the world right now.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Mr. Rashid has written a valuable history lesson concerning Afghanistan and the surrounding countries playing a role in the problems of current Central Asia. All the players are carefully analyzed as to motivation and intent. The happenings in this area of the world from ancient times up to (but not including) the attack on America is reviewed in great detail. Rashid is obviously a knowledgeable man with terrific insight into this area of the world and his powerful book should be read by every American who wants to better understand the issues and movements leading up to Sept. 11 2001. Again, every American should read this book.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Mr. Rashid has done a superb job of bringing the history of Afganistan, Pakistan, the Central Asian Republics and the rest of the world to life. I found his book spellbinding because of the events going on now and also his clear style. He does not talk down to his reader. He expects us to follow along closely. He describes the history and thought processes in several different ways. Economic, cultural, military and diplomatic histories are laid down, one after another. Any one of them was a great learning experience. All of them together weaves a complex web. There is no single clear answer at the end but there ARE many partial answers that will be much better than hoping the Taliban will go away by themselves. There is no nation that has done great things for Afganistan. But there is certainly some groups within nations who have done really terrible things to the Afgan people. Some of those groups are outside Afganistan but not many. Most of the really terrible things have been done, can only be done by those on the ground in the country. Mr. Rashid is probably not well-liked in several countries of the world right now. But one of my strongest compliments was that I could not tell what his own religion was from his book. Mr. Rashid has done the world a great favor with his first-hand accounts. I pray we read his book and do what we need to stop the evil and keep the good, ordinary people growing in that region of the world. I am buying copies of the book for my friends and co-workers.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Rashid's insightful study of Afghanistan's Taliban regime bases his account on detailed reporting and travel throughout Afghanistan and interviews conducted with many of the Taliban' s elusive leaders. As a narrative, it is gripping and well researched reporting that provides a glimpse at a secretive society.
Ramirez on LibraryThing 1 days ago
A good book on the recent history of Afghanistan.It help us to understand how an insignificant country became the safe harbor of terrorism, making 9/11 possible.It also tells us how the West has failed in the subsequent period: Bush didn't cared about reconstruction, sparing money and men for the Iraqi adventure. Thus he enabled Taliban resurgence.Rashid is the most authoritative voice in this field and this book may help us to define our opinion on this issue- without either mad militarism or blind isolationism.
naveensreedevan 9 months ago
Lets face this simple truth. america is not a military might. thy are only bullying the other developed nations to keep quiet while they massacre the poor people in Asia/Africa/Middle east. So we can easily defeat these bastards. America is now dependent on us for trade. On china/Europe/Japan/Russia for military cooperation and technology! yes that is the truth. These p[ussies dont know anything on theirown. This is golden chance for the rest of World esp. Asia to defeat these tyrants who are weaker than us. War Strategy for Afghan/Taliban/Yemen/Africa: America/Saudi can be made to surrender. Else, if we allow America to continue decide the course of war, it will never end. Vietnam, congo saga will continue endlessly. Congo alone last 30 years more than 5 million civilians killed. south sudan, rwanda, niger etc. It seems to me this is like a cards Poker Game. America is winning this war game as the own the Bank which is actually printing worthless US dollar and quite a bit is counterfeited in North korea etc. which American military planes supply to the military officials of their agents and other traitors/politicians such as President /traitor Hamid karzai of Afghan. How to win this War against AMerican/NATO mob: Final assauult. Yemen/Afghan Army/rebels should drop a few hydro/atomic bombs at military bases( see Black Hawk Down movie and Bierut base bmobing 1980s killing 100s USA army and so USA back off.) Then a finally a big Bomb on House of porn saud palace. And Later Russia/china can ask America to stop the war or else face trade boycot from Asia. And no more will our OEM vendors supply tech products for Silicon valley. AMerica is having $50 trillion debt so the can go to hell. So Russia/china should use common sense and defeat them on war and economic front. this is the best option to end this mindless killing game of mob street fighters i.e these are mobsters dressed in military/3 piece office dress. America's war aim has two goals. Short term goal is to terrorise the world and long term goals as we see in vietnam is to control the government.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
This book is banned in Central Asia because of the author’s criticism of various regimes in that region of the world. First published in 2000, it gained greater significance after September 11th because of the connection of Al Qaeda and the Taliban. The second edition is reviewed. It covers the period of 2000 to 2009. The book begins with a detailed history of the Taliban movement. The Taliban fought the Soviets in Afghanistan. They were the latest in a long line of warriors in that region. Included in the Taliban were Pashtun nationals. The author explains how the Pashtun’s developed as fighters. They have a long history of fighting and helped develop the state of Afghanistan. Islam has historically been the unifying spirit of Afghanistan’s diverse peoples. The theme of the second part of the book is how Islam and the Taliban connected. Traditionally Islam has been a tolerant religion. But in 1992 the civil war in Afghanistan was characterized by brutality as various religious sects fought each other. The author explains the complex issues and events that tore the country asunder. He specifically covers how the Taliban began as an Islamic reform movement then became the extremists behind the bloodshed. Today the oil companies compete in Central Asia in what the author calls “The New Great Game.” The game is between expanding and contracting empires as Russia, Turkey and Pakistan build oil pipelines. China too has an interest in the area because it has Muslim ethnic groups related to peoples in Central Asia. In this book a large swath of history is looked at in order to explain the often complex and convoluted issues that have characterized Central Asia for many decades. The Soviet era is discussed in detail because it was formative to the issues still prevalent there today. The conclusion of the book begins with a statement that Afghanistan as a viable state has ceased to exist. The country has reverted to a tribal mentality. The Taliban is behind this sectarianism and ethnic cleansing. The author blames the outside powers for the destruction of Afghanistan. As well he condemns the Taliban’s negative interpretation of Islam. He says the Taliban refuse to define the Afghan state because they have no idea about what they want. So the country subsists on smuggling and drug trafficking. Now we have Al Qaeda militants in the country and the current Karzai government unable to rule. The Taliban are their protectors. The big question is: will any US troops remain in Afghanistan to fight Al Qaeda after 2014? This book is a useful resource for anyone who has an interest in the answer to that question.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago