Today, two cultural forces are converging to make America's youth easy targets for sex traffickers. Younger and younger girls are engaging in adult sexual attitudes and practices, and the pressure to conform means thousands have little self-worth and are vulnerable to exploitation. At the same time, thanks to social media, texting, and chatting services, predators are able to ferret out their victims more easily than ever before. In Walking Prey, advocate and former victim Holly Austin Smith shows how middle class suburban communities are fast becoming the new epicenter of sex trafficking in America. Smith speaks from experience: Without consistent positive guidance or engagement, Holly was ripe for exploitation at age fourteen. A chance encounter with an older man led her to run away from home, and she soon found herself on the streets of Atlantic City. Her experience led her, two decades later, to become one of the foremost advocates for trafficking victims. Smith argues that these young women should be treated as victims by law enforcement, but that too often the criminal justice system lacks the resources and training to prevent the vicious cycle of prostitution. This is a clarion call to take a sharp look at one of the most striking human rights abuses, and one that is going on in our own backyard.
|Publisher:||St. Martin's Press|
|Product dimensions:||6.40(w) x 9.10(h) x 1.00(d)|
About the Author
Holly Austin Smith is an advocate for human trafficking victims who speaks about her own experience nationwide. After becoming a victim of child sex trafficking at the age of 14, she nearly committed suicide while the man who abducted her served only one year in prison. Her story has been featured on the Dr. Oz show, as well as in the Associated Press, the Richmond Times Dispatch, the Tampa Bay Times, Cosmopolitan magazine, and Dallas Morning News. Smith writes a weekly column for the Washington Times Communities, and she has submitted testimony to Congress. She has consulted for the National Criminal Justice Training Center and AMBER Alert Training and Technical Assistance Program. She is in constant demand as a speaker, speaking over 30 times in 2012 at universities, law enforcement agencies, and government-sponsored symposiums. She lives in Richmond, VA.
Read an Excerpt
How America's Youth are Vulnerable to Sex Slavery
By Holly Austin Smith
St. Martin's PressCopyright © 2014 Holly Austin Smith
All rights reserved.
ARE YOUR CHILDREN AT RISK?
Many parents want to believe that their children are safe from the tactics of child sex traffickers; however, the truth is that any child can be susceptible. The very nature of being a child is a risk factor as youth often act on emotion and impulse. In a 2011 podcast, Sandra Morgan, R.N., discussed how brain maturation can effect the balance of power between children and traffickers. Morgan explained that a "brain develops from the back to the front" and that the prefrontal lobe, which is "where executive decision-making is housed" is "one of the last parts of [the] brain to develop. ... You have a major advantage when you're a 26-year-old adult and she's a 14-year-old child," Morgan says, "This is ... really important ... to understand because executive decision-making is that ability to measure the consequences, to assess the risk, and [to ask oneself] Is this a good choice? Is this responsible? Will this produce a good result for me?"
Daniel Romer, Ph.D., argues that adolescents are naturally prone to experiment with "novel (adult-like) behavior" and that their impulsivity and risk-taking is due to their lack of experience with such behavior as opposed to "a structural deficit" in brain maturation. Regardless of the root cause, impulsivity and risky behavior are natural adolescent attributes, and such attributes are attractive to traffickers. Greg told me that he was 23 or 25; however, he was actually 31. Based on police records, I believe Nicki was 26 years old. At fourteen, I believed I was capable of making independent decisions. In reality, I was being manipulated and exploited by adults. It took many years for me to recognize that, though. I needed time to mature in order to understand how inexperienced and immature I was at age fourteen.
Along with impulsivity and lack of experience, there are other factors that might predispose a child to being more vulnerable to a trafficker's tactics. The greater the number (or severity) of these risk factors, the greater the risk is for that child if he or she encounters a trafficker. The following potential predisposing factors are often associated with the commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC); however, this list is non- exhaustive, and none of these factors predestine a child to become a victim of commercial sexual exploitation, including sex trafficking. However, any vulnerability puts a child at a greater risk for any type of exploitation.
ABUSE AND/OR NEGLECT IN CHILDHOOD
A 2012 Ohio Human Trafficking Commission report listed the following "early indicators" as "experiences of Ohio youth before involvement in the child sex trade: 41% were victims of neglect, 44% were victims of abuse, 40% were victims of sex abuse, 37% were victims of emotional abuse/psychological maltreatment, and 24% were victims of physical abuse." These experiences happened to the youth at least one year or more "before entering the sex trade," and each of these indicators was listed as statistically significant. Any type of unaddressed trauma in childhood can manifest in any number of negative ways, including self-loathing, depression, and anger. These manifestations are layers of additional risk factors.
Sexual abuse in childhood is by far the most common predisposing factor I've heard mentioned in discussions regarding CSEC within the United States. A 1983 study found that 60 percent of 200 subjects involved in commercial sex (adults and minors) were sexually exploited as juveniles. A 2012 study found that 40.8 percent of 115 subjects who identify as "being involved in the sex trade before age 18" also report having been victims of "sex abuse." Patricia Murphy cites two studies in her book, Making the Connections, that estimate that between 65 and 85 percent of prostituted women were the victims of "childhood rape." In fact, some clinicians estimate this figure to be "nearer to 100 percent." Many organizations that provide services to child victims of commercial sexual exploitation across the country have confirmed these higher statistics to me. Early childhood sexual abuse will be discussed more in depth in the following chapter.
Whether a child's family or entire community is impoverished, poverty can limit that child's options and resources. The National Center for Children in Poverty (NCCP) states that poverty can impede a child's ability to learn, can contribute to poor health and mental health, and can contribute to social, emotional, and behavioral problems. Rachel Lloyd of Girls Educational & Mentoring Services (GEMS) works with child victims of commercial sexual exploitation in New York City. In her memoir, Girls Like Us, she describes the pervasive effects of poverty on children:
Of course many children who grow up in challenging economic situations thrive, but the reality is that far too many don't, and too many children's futures can be determined by zip code. Children in poor neighborhoods frequently receive a substandard education, are often exposed to lead paint in poorly constructed buildings, have higher rates of asthma, and live in communities where there are little to no recreational or green spaces and where entire neighborhoods have been abandoned and forgotten by those in power. Children born into poverty are at risk for many things, including being recruited into the commercial sex industry.
The story of Antonia "Neet" Childs, Founder of Market Your Mind Not Your Body and Neet's Sweets bakery, exemplifies the significance of this risk factor. As a child, Neet lived in New York where her mother struggled financially. "My mom worked hard to take care of us," Neet said, "and I always felt like I needed to help and support her." Without resources to help her family, Neet began caring for her brother and sisters at an early age. "I always carry this habit of having to help everybody," Neet said in a 2013 interview with Ebony magazine. "I had seen my mother struggle and I didn't want that for her. I wanted to do everything in my power to help."
At sixteen, Neet started working at an after-school job where she met a man. For several months, this man visited Neet and asked her questions about her life. Their conversations developed into a friendship, and Neet confided her family's struggles. This man, who posed as a friend, began to drive Neet home after her work shifts ended. "He would give me $100 bills at a time," Neet said, "As a teenager ... a hundred dollars is a lot of money." The man's monetary gifts ultimately led to requests for sex. Because she had accepted money from this man, Neet says she felt both responsible and obligated to concede. The man soon began trafficking Neet to other men within a high-profile fraternity. This man preyed on Neet's vulnerability for his own profit.
HISTORY OF FOSTER CARE/CHILD PROTECTIVE SERVICES
Without a doubt, a history of foster care or child protective services is also a risk factor commonly discussed in child sex trafficking and other forms of CSEC within the United States. Tina Frundt, Founder and Executive Director of Courtney's House, cycled through more than twenty foster homes in Chicago, Illinois, before she was trafficked on her fourteenth birthday. "I was adopted to a wonderful family when I was twelve years old," Tina says in a 2012 training video for AMBER Alert, "but because of prior sexual abuse ... my trust on people was really low." Tina was lured away from her adoptive family by a man who claimed to have also grown up in foster care. Tina later learned that this was a lie; it was a tactic the trafficker used to bond with Tina and to gain her trust. The man then drove Tina to Cleveland, Ohio.
"And that is when he brought two guys into the room and they 'seasoned' me," Tina explained in a 2010 interview with Free the Slaves. "'Seasoned' is rape."
Withelma "T" Ortiz Walker Pettigrew, a trafficking survivor named 2011 Woman of the Year by Glamour magazine, described her early life in a 2013 Al Jazeera interview: "Like Tina [Frundt], [I] was raised in the foster care system ... From the age of basically birth to ten years old, I endured various different multiple levels of abuse — verbal, sexual, physical — which made me really vulnerable [to a trafficker] at the age of 10 years old when I was used to being more mature than my age because of my circumstance[s] ..."
In November 2012, Abby Sewell wrote in the Los Angeles Times that "[o]f the 174 juveniles arrested on prostitution-related charges in Los Angeles County in 2010, 59% were in the foster care system, according to Probation Department statistics." Melissa Snow, Child Sex Trafficking Program Specialist with the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC), stated that "[o]f the children reported missing to [NCMEC] who [were] likely child sex trafficking victims, 60 percent were in the care of social services or foster care when they ran."
Kids living in foster care and other child protective services are not only vulnerable to exploitation — they are sometimes directly targeted by predators. A Miami Herald article described a case in which four "alleged pimps" targeted children living in the foster care system. The article described how the men "[used] a teenage foster child as a recruiter" and then "plied [the] underage girls with cash, affection, and gifts." One of the victims, a 17-year-old girl, was stated to have "cognitive impairments." The article described how the girl was recruited by her peer and then sexually exploited by two of the alleged pimps. These men then sold her to other men; they would call her cell phone and pick her up from school or from the state facility. Commercial sexual exploitation involving children with developmental disabilities is not uncommon, making this another risk factor.
DIFFICULTY IN SCHOOL
The 2012 Ohio Human Trafficking Commission's report claimed that one of the three statistically significant factors for child victims of commercial sexual exploitation was "dropping out of school"; these factors occurred less than one year before victimization. A 2002 research study, "Sisters Speak Out," found similar results; it was based on interviews with 222 women "representing various segments of the prostitution industry." Of those women first commercially sexually exploited between the ages of twelve and fifteen, only one-fourth reported completion of a high school education or GED. A child may struggle in school for any number of reasons: bullying, poor nutrition, lack of support with homework, etc. Dropping out of school can expose a child or teenager to many negative outcomes, including commercial sexual exploitation.
A child may run away from home for any number of reasons: to seek attention, to escape abuse or neglect, to seek acceptance, to seek opportunities for survival, etc. Running away is a risk factor; and the more times the child runs away, the greater the risk factor. Sergeant Byron Fassett with the Dallas Police Department recognized that children who ran away four or more times in a year were more likely to have been involved with commercial sex. The story of author and attorney Carissa Phelps is an example of this vulnerability. In her memoir Runaway Girl, Phelps describes a childhood on the run:
I decided I couldn't stay put for another minute. I bolted. Out the bathroom window, onto the roof, and over the back fence. I ran away. I left without any plans of coming back. A surge of adrenaline rushed through me. I was everything I wanted to be — out of the house, out from under my [stepfather's] roof, away from the voices and the mess, out on my own. I was free.
A chronic runaway, Carissa attempted to flee her parents' dysfunctional homes, as well as detention centers and other youth facilities. She was ultimately trafficked by a brutal pimp at the age of twelve in Fresno, California. Staca Shehan, Director of the Case Analysis Division for NCMEC reports the following glaring statistic: one out of eight endangered runaways reported missing to NCMEC in 2012 was likely [a] child sex trafficking victim. This is not surprising as traffickers, especially pimp and gang traffickers, will often hang around bus stations and youth shelters in search of young victims.
The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Virginia reports several cases of gang-controlled sex trafficking in which runaways were targeted. In July 2011, Alexander Rivas, an MS-13 gang member, was sentenced to ten years in prison for luring juvenile runaways into a sex trafficking ring with a majority of his activity happening in northern Virginia, including Woodbridge, Fairfax, and Alexandria. Months later, Alonso Bruno Cornejo Ormeno, 22, was sentenced to 292 months in prison, followed by five years of supervised release, for sex trafficking girls who ranged in age from fifteen to seventeen. Cornejo Ormeno targeted teenage girls who had run away from home and served them up to clients throughout northern Virginia, as well as Washington, D.C. and Maryland.
MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES
The Ohio Human Trafficking Commission's 2012 study reports depression as an "early indicator" in 30 percent of Ohio youth "before involvement in the child sex trade." Depression is often cited as a risk factor, and I strongly believe this is true. For me, signs of depression began as early as fourth or fifth grade and were severe by eighth grade, along with anxiety and impulsivity. Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is also gaining attention as a potential risk factor for and effect of commercial sexual exploitation.
However, symptoms associated with any mental health issue may be a risk factor for any type of exploitation, including CSEC. The 2007 New York Study of Commercial Sexual Exploitation reports that 25 of 27 victims incarcerated in juvenile detention facilities for prostitution-related offenses had "records of previous mental health treatment." Obviously, lack of efficacious mental health treatment is also a risk factor for exploitation.
HAVING FAMILY MEMBERS OR FRIENDS INVOLVED IN COMMERCIAL SEX
NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth reported a story in January 2012 in which a "Houston-area man and his girlfriend [were] accused of forcing her 14-year-old daughter into prostitution at truck stops and apartments." NBC 5 says that both adults were arrested "when a neighbor called police after noticing the girl near a street. The neighbor said the girl was barefoot and seemed hungry." The Houston Chronicle wrote: "Court documents show that the girl told investigators she initially accompanied her mother to apartments where the woman was prostituting herself. Customers began asking to have sex with the girl, who said she was then forced to act as a prostitute 'every day' during several weeks.
Sadly, this story exemplifies the risk associated with having relatives or friends involved with illegal commercial sex, including sex trafficking. Sisters Speak Out says that "over half of the early starters grew up in a household with prostitution." "Early starters" are reported as those women participants who were first commercially sexually exploited between the ages twelve and fifteen. The study also reports that 87 percent of "early starters had someone suggest they engage in prostitution while they were growing up." The Ohio Attorney General's 2012 report says that 33 percent of commercially sexually exploited youth have a close family member involved in the "sex trade." This report also says that 59 percent have friends involved with selling themselves and 30 percent have friends involved with selling others.
In March 2012, Project Q Atlanta reported that Atlanta drag queen personality Pasha Nicole received a fourteen-year prison sentence for "forcing a transgender teenager into prostitution," among other offenses related to sex trafficking. Nicole, known legally as Christopher Thomas Lynch, was charged alongside 35-year-old roommate and gay bar "go-go dancer," Steven Donald Lemery. In September 2012, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported that Lemery was sentenced to 80 years in prison for human trafficking, aggravated child molestation, and enticing a child for indecent purposes and pandering by compulsion. The article quotes Assistant District Attorney Rachel Ackley:
Two of Lemery's victims were 15 years old at the time of the offenses, and a third was 18 ... One of the 15-year-olds and the 18-year-old were brought across state lines by Lemery and forced into prostitution ... There was testimony how victims were held in the house, not allowed to leave, given drugs and alcohol ... One of the victims testified at trial [about] being forced to prostitute and while being held at a client's house, he was held down and burned as they attempted to rape them.
This case illustrates one of the many dangers faced by LGBTQ youth who are forced (or feel compelled) to seek support and solace outside their homes or communities. An anonymous survivor of child sex trafficking explained how her confusion over sexual orientation added to her vulnerability as an adolescent: "Even though I was often seeking romantic relationships with boys, I was physically attracted to girls in middle school. And I thought I was in love with someone, but I couldn't tell her. I felt like I couldn't tell anyone. Being gay or bisexual wasn't talked about; it was taboo. I didn't have anyone to help me sort through those feelings."
Excerpted from Walking Prey by Holly Austin Smith. Copyright © 2014 Holly Austin Smith. Excerpted by permission of St. Martin's Press.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Table of Contents
Foreword Mira Sorvino v
Part I Before Atlantic City
1 Are Your Children at Risk? 23
2 The "Willing Victim" 35
3 Community Risk Factors 45
4 Advertising to Children and Teens 59
5 Negative Messages in Popular Culture 71
6 Violence against Women 81
Part II Atlantic City
7 The Buyers 93
8 Control and Violence 105
9 Traffickers and the Rules of Trafficking 115
10 The "Rescue" 127
Part III After Atlantic City
11 Immediate Aftercare for Child Victims of Commercial Sexual Exploitation 141
12 Intermediate and Long-term Aftercare 153
13 Prevention and Advocacy 167
Appendix A Resources for Parents and Victims 187
Appendix B Resources for Law Enforcement and Other First Responders 189
Appendix C 10 Tips for Teens for Protection against Traffickers 199
Appendix D 10 Tips for Parents to Protect Your Children from Predators 202
Appendix E 10 Tips for Elementary School Teachers and Counselors 204
Appendix F 10 Tips for Middle School Teachers and Counselors 206
Appendix G PESS #1-Psychiatric Emergency Screening Services on July 11, 1992 209
Appendix H Discharge Summary #1 213
Appendix I PESS #2-Psychiatric Emergency Screening Services on August 7, 1992 218
Appendix J Discharge Summary #2 222