Cliché Ridden and Contrived
I can honestly say that I hated Wild Roses by Deb Caletti. This novel is about seventeen year-old Cassie Morgan, a girl who divides her time between her divorced parents' houses. Her mother married Dino Cavalli, renowned Italian violinist- who happens to be mean, critical, and paranoid. The story is told from Cassie's point of view. The story is narrated with forced sarcasm and is filled to the brim with nauseating clichés and metaphors. Caletti tries hard to make Cassie seem like a typical teen and make her world realistic, but it never really works. I didn't care about this protaganist at all and I cared even less about what happened to her. The dialogue was stilted and unbelievable- the author seemed to be under the impression that if she used the words sh*t and f*ck every other sentence it would make her characters' (especially her teen ones) dialogue seem more natural. And this totally worked. Not. Anyway, Dino has a big concert coming up and a record deal, for which he needs to compose three new pieces. To add structure to his life and help his creative process, Dino takes a student. He is the young violinist Ian Waters, a prodigy hoping to get a scholarship to Curtis, and is hoping that Dino can help him prepare for the audition. Alright, you judge if this is realistic. Cassie is one day standing at her bedroom window and then she she sees a boy bicycling up the street towards her house. Mind you, she is looking through a window that is two stories high. And suddenly Cassie is overwhelmed by a wave of emotion for this boy, a longing. And it's like, what?! She's never met him, can barely see him. He's just this random boy riding on a bike and all of a sudden she's obsessed with him. Just like that. Okay, maybe if you're going for the whole love at first sight angle it makes sense. But this idea totally didn't fit in with this story, this work of supposedly realistic fiction. Is it desire she's feeling perhaps? That would be more understandable. But she can barely see him! All she can see is that he has black hair and his black coat is flapping in the breeze as he approaches on his bike. Anyway, the boy turns out to be be Ian and (of course) they fall in love. But, oops!, their love is forbidden because Dino forbids him to have a romantic relationship so all his concentration will be on his music. During the whole story I looked for a reason for Ian and Cassie to be in love. I searched in vain and I never found one. They have nothing in common except for a shared dislike of Dino. The author simply tells you they are in love and expects you to believe it, the same way that she tells you Cassie loves astronomy. She has Cassie take out her telescope occaisonally and visit a planetarium, but none of her actions express a true love for what she's doing or even much of an interest. This novel is populated by stereotypical characters, from the girl Nicole Hower at school that Cassie describes as "Nickname whore... because her clothes gave the impression that she wanted to share her boobs with makind" to Dino Cavalli himself, as the crazed musical genius. Caletti's attempt to explore madness fails. Her overuse of examples of artists who were mentally ill/comitted suicide were too numerous and overdone. To summarize, I wouldn't reccomend this book unless you're looking for a dull, often preachy book with a terribly annoying heroine.
4 out of 5 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.