"We have the intriguing possibility that the nextgreat American author is already in print." —Fort Worth Star-Telegram
When Sheila McGann setsout to redeem her disgraced brother, a once-beloved Catholic priest in suburbanBoston, her quest will force her to confront cataclysmic truths about herfractured Irish-American family, her beliefs, and, ultimately, herself.Award-winning author Jennifer Haigh follows hercritically acclaimed novels Mrs. Kimbleand The Condition with a captivating,vividly rendered portrait of fraying family ties, and the trials of belief anddevotion, in Faith.
About the Author
Jennifer Haigh is the author of the short-story collection News from Heaven and four critically acclaimed novels: Faith, The Condition, Baker Towers, and Mrs. Kimble. Her books have won both the PEN/Hemingway Award for debut fiction and the PEN/L.L. Winship Award for work by a New England writer. Her short fiction has been published widely, in The Atlantic, Granta, The Best American Short Stories, and many other places. She lives in Boston.
Date of Birth:October 16, 1968
Place of Birth:Barnesboro, Pennsylvania
Education:B.A., Dickinson College, 1990; M.F.A., Iowa Writers' Workshop, 2002
Read an Excerpt
By Jennifer Haigh
HarperCollinsCopyright © 2011 Jennifer Haigh
All right reserved.
Here is a story my mother has never told me.
It is a day she's relived a thousand times, the twenty-first
of June, 1951, the longest day of that or any year. A day that still
hasn't ended, as some part of her still paces that dark apartment in
Jamaica Plain, waiting. I imagine the curtains closed against the
five o'clock sun, hot and bright as midday; her baby boy peacefully
asleep; her young self with nothing to do but wander from
room to room, still filled with her dead mother-in-law's things.
At the time she'd thought it a grand apartment, her from Roxbury
where the children slept three to a bed. Even as a boy her
husband had had his own bedroom, an unimaginable luxury. His
mother had been injured somehow giving birth and there had
been no more children. This fact alone made the Breens wealthier
than most, though Harry's father had only worked at Filene's
stacking crates in the warehouse. The entire apartment had come
from Filene's, on the employee discount, the lamps and brocade
divan and what she had learned were called Oriental rugs. Mary
herself had never bought a thing at Filene's. Her own mother
shopped at Sears.
In the bedroom the baby slept deeply. She parted the curtains
and let the sun shine on his face. Harry, when he came home,
would pull them shut, worried someone might see him dressing
or undressing through their third-floor windows. Sure, it was
possiblethe windows faced Pond Street, also lined with three-
deckersthough why he cared was a puzzle. He was a man, after
all. And there was nothing wrong with the sight of him. The first
morning of their marriage, lying in the too-soft bed in the tourist
cabin in Wellfleet, she had looked up at him in wonderment, her
first time seeing him in daylight, his bare chest and shoulders, and
her already four months along. Nothing wrong with him at all,
her husband tall and blue-eyed, with shiny dark hair that fell into
his eyes when he ducked his head, a habit left over from a bashful
adolescence, though nobody, now, would call him shy. Harry
Breen could talk to anyone. Behind the counter at Old Colony
Hardware he had a way with the customers, got them going about
their clogged pipes and screen doors and cabinets they were
installing. He complimented their plans, suggested small improvements,
sent them out the door with twice what they'd come in
for. A natural salesman, never mind that he couldn't, himself, hit
a nail with a hammer. When a fuse blew at the apartment it was
Mary who ventured into the dark basement with a flashlight.
What did you do before? she'd asked, half astonished, when she
returned to the lit apartment and found Harry and his mother sitting
placidly in the kitchen, stirring sugar into teacups.
We didn't burn so many lights before, the old lady said.
It was a reminder among many others that Mary's presence
was unwelcome, that Mrs. Breen, at least, had not invited her
into their lives, this grimy interloper with her swollen belly and
her skirts and blouses from Sears. As though her condition were a
mystery on the order of the Virgin Birth, as though Harry Breen
had had nothing to do with it.
She lifted Arthur from his crib and gave his bottom a pat.
He wriggled, squealed, fumbled blindly for her breast. The sodden
diaper would have to be changed, the baby fed. In this way
minutes would pass, and finally an hour. The stubborn sun would
begin its grudging descent. Across town, in Roxbury, girls would
be dressing for the dances, Clare Boyle and her sister and whoever
else they ran with now, setting out by twos and threes down the
hill to Dudley Street.
She finished with the diaper, then sat at the window and
unbuttoned her blouse, aware of the open curtains. If Harry came
upon her like this, her swollen breast exposed, what would he
do then? The thought was thrilling in a way she couldn't have
explained. But it was after six, and still there was no sign of him.
When his mother was alive he'd come straight home after work.
You could set your watch by it, his footsteps on the stairs at five
thirty exactly, even on Fridays when the other men stopped at the
pub for a taste. Lately, though, his habits had shifted. Mondays
and Tuesdays he played cards at the Vets.
Once, leaving church, he'd nodded to some men she didn't
recognize, a short one and a tall one sharing a cigarette on the
sidewalk. See you tomorrow, then, Harry called in a friendly tone.
The short man had muttered under his breath, and the tall one
had guffawed loudly. To Mary it couldn't have been plainer that
they were not Harry's friends.
They'd met the way everyone met, at the dances. Last summer
the Intercolonial was the place to be; now it might be the Hibernian-
or the Winslow or the Rose Croix for all she knew. On a
Saturday night, with Johnny Powell's band playing, a thousand or
more would crowd upstairs at the Intercolonial, a mirrored globe
hanging from the ceiling so that the walls shivered with light.
She was seventeen then, too young for such pleasures. But it
had been easy enough to slip out on a Friday night with Ma
dead asleep, exhausted by the work of getting three small ones
bathed and in their beds. And it wasn't even a lie to go dancing
on a Wednesday, when Mary really did attend the novena at
nine o'clock as she was supposed to, the church packed with other
overdressed girls and men who'd already had a drink or two,
who'd meet up later across the street at Fontaine's Café and make
their plans for the evening. All right, then. See you at the hall. The
men were deep on Wednesdays; you could change partners all
night long if you wanted. Thursdays were a different story, maids'
night out, the halls packed with Irish girls. There was almost no
point in going on a Thursday, the numbers were so against you.
On a Thursday you were lucky to get a single dance.
Harry Breen hadn't chosen her, not at first. That first time
they'd danced purely by chance. She knew all the dancesthe reels
and jigs, the wild céilí. At the Intercolonial waltzes were the thing,
though once each night Johnny Powell would force the dreamy
couples apart. Line up, everybody, for the Siege of Ennis. A mad crush,
then, as they formed two long lines, men and girls facing. You'd
take your turn with every one, herself and Clare Boyle laughing
the whole way through. Some of the men were clumsy, some so
strong they'd nearly swing you off your feet.
She noticed Harry a moment before he reached for her. He
was taller than the rest, his movements liquid; he swung her
gracefully, smooth and controlled. And that thing she first felt,
that swooning joy: maybe it was simple geometry, the relative
size and shape of their bodies, his chest and shoulders just where
they should be, their hips meeting, her eyes level with his mouth.
The plain fact was that she'd chased him, courted his attention
Gone to greater lengths than any girl should. There was
no point, now, in being ashamed. She had a ring on her finger
and it hardly mattered how. They were married fast by her uncle
Fergus, who'd skipped, discreetly, the time-consuming step of
publishing the banns. Fergus had guessed what everyone would
soon know, that Mary had gotten exactly what she wanted, and
a bit more besides.
She looked down at the baby at her breast.
In the kitchen she took her beads from the drawer and found
the station in time. Missing the Archbishop's greeting was like
coming late to a movie; she'd be unable to enter into the spirit
of the thing. When Harry's mother was living, they had knelt in
the parlor for the rosary. Now the old lady was gone and no one
was looking, so Mary dragged a chair to the open window and
settled herself there. I believe in God the Father Almighty, Creator of
Heaven and Earth. Through the window a breeze came, carrying
the Archbishop's voice from the two apartments below. Up
and down the street, every radio was tuned to the same station.
Through every open window came the same holy words.
It being Thursday, they started with the Joyful. As a girl she
had studied the illustrations in her mother's missal. The Joyful
Mysteries were the most straightforward, the pictures almost
Protestant in their simplicity: the Blessed Virgin kneeling in prayer,
waiting for the angel; the Virgin noticeably pregnant, embracing
her cousin Elizabeth. The Sorrowful were haunting and in a
way lovelier: Our Lord kneeling in the Garden of Gethsemane,
glowing in His anguish, perspiring drops of blood. But it was the
Glorious Mysteries she waited for, Our Lord lifted into heaven,
clouds bubbling beneath His feet like a cauldron of spirits. The
Resurrection, the Ascension, the Assumption of the Virgin: all
these stirred her deeply, even though (or perhaps because) she
understood them the least. That was the beauty of it: contemplating
the miracles, sublime and unknowable, and yet the words you
repeated couldn't be simpler. Hail Mary, full of grace. A prayer you'd
known since earliest childhood, familiar as your mother's voice.
She closed her eyes and enjoyed the breeze, the baby's warm
weight, the Archbishop's familiar intonations. She had seen him
once standing beside the carousel at Paragon Park, eating ice
cream with a dozen beaming nuns. In photos, in full regalia,
he was imposing, and yet you never forgot that he was from St.
Eulalia's in South Boston, that his own father had worked in the
repair pits at the Boston El. He never forgot it, either. You could
tell this from the photographs: the Archbishop tossing around a
football with the CYO boys, or raising a glass at a priest's golden
jubilee. The Archbishop wouldn't say no to a drink, according to
her uncle Fergus, who'd met him on several occasions. Cushing
was God's own, and yet he was theirs, too, in every way a regular
She heard two sharp knocks at the front door.
"Coming," she called, drying herself with a tea towel, noticing
all at once the wet stains on her blouse.
She threw open the door. A strange man stood there smoking
a cigarette. He wore a thin mustache and was her own height,
though she was barefoot and he wore heeled boots. It took her
a moment to place him: the short man from outside the church.
"Is your husband at home?" He looked over her shoulder, his
eyes darting around the room.
"I'm sorry, he's not."
From the kitchen the Archbishop droned: Glory be to the Father
and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost.
"Listening to the rosary, were you? My mum does that every
night." The man dropped his cigarette and crushed it with his
heel. He stepped past her into the apartment. "You're sure he isn't
here?" He glanced into the kitchen as though Harry might be
hiding and Mary felt a sudden urge to laugh, a nervous tic. She
was forever laughing at the wrong times.
"He hasn't come home yet. Try the store, maybe?"
"I've been there. He left hours ago."
"I don't know, then. He could have stopped off at the pub."
The man frowned. "Never seen him take a drink, myself.
Likes to keep his wits about him, doesn't he?" He smiled then,
and she saw that on both sides his teeth were missing. It made
the front ones look suspect, like the vampire dentures children
wore at Halloween.
In her arms the baby let out a loud hiccup. She raised him to
her shoulder. "Excuse me. I was in the middle of feeding him."
Patting him gently, waiting for him to burp. She was afraid to
look down at her blouse.
The man stepped in close to her, smelling rankly of cigarette.
"Sorry to miss that," he said, and to her horror his rough hand
touched her face.
Arthur let out another hiccup and vomited in a great burst.
"Jaysus!" The man stepped back, shaking his sleeve. It was
coated in yellow spew.
"Oh, no! I'm so sorry." Mary took the towel from her shoulder
and wiped uselessly at his sleeve. The smell was terrible, sour as
vinegar. The man tore his hand away, eyeing the baby like a snake.
"That's a real charmer you've got there." He turned to go.
"Tell your man Shorty wants to see him."
She closed the door quickly behind him. The door, then the
bolt, then the chain.
Tell your man Shorty wants to see him.
He had never, in her memory, stayed out after dark. Only for
the card games, and then he always told her beforehand: I've got
the cards tonight, so don't hold supper. I'll have a sandwich or something
If he stayed out all night, would she sit up waiting? Brushing
her teeth a hundred strokes, a hundred strokes to her long
dark hair. Always the counting calmed herbrushstrokes, rosary
beads. Half the reason she loved the dancing was the counting of
the steps. It gave her mind something to do.
A strange fear gnawed at her stomach. For the first time she
wished for a regular man, who'd go to a pub on a Friday. Then, at
least, she'd know where to find him. But it was true what Shorty
had said: Harry liked to keep a clear head. There was nothing to
do but go to Old Colony Hardware. As detectives did in the radio
serials: she would go to where Harry was last seen.
I've been there, Shorty had said. He left hours ago.
How many hours? she wondered. Where on earth could he
She went to the telephone. "Is Father Egan in, please? This is
his niece, Mary Breen." The name new enough, still, to have an
odd flavor on her tongue.
"Wedding tonight," the housekeeper said. "He'll be back late.
I can have him call you tomorrow."
"Yes, please," Mary said.
Excerpted from Faith by Jennifer Haigh Copyright © 2011 by Jennifer Haigh. Excerpted by permission of HarperCollins. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
Best book I've read in a long time. Well written, sensitively told family story about a devout Roman Catholic family with buried secrets. I literally couldn't stop reading it, and snuck off to read it whenever I had a free minute. I finished it in one day. I've read and enjoyed all of Jennifer Haigh's novels but this was my favorite. An intelligent, thought provoking page turner.
Haigh sets her story in Boston in 2004, shortly after scandal began to rock the Catholic diocese. Many priests had been accused of sexually abusing young people, and the large Catholic community was devastated. Sheila McGann tells the story of her half-brother, Art Breen, a priest accused by an eight-year-old boy's mother of molesting her son. There is an element of mystery to the novel as Sheila attempts to discover whether the charges are true. Art's mother, a devout Catholic, believes her son could never do what he is accused of. Sheila's brother Mike, a former cop and father of three young boys, is disgusted, believing that no eight-year-old boy could lie about being molested. Sheila supports Art, but has her doubts. The title of the book, Faith, is brilliant, for this is a book not about religious faith, but more about faith in your family. Sheila says to Mike, "Sorry, Mike, but sooner or later you have to decide what you believe." It was a thing I'd always known but until recently had forgotten: that faith is a decision. In its most basic form, it is a choice. I love those lines, because faith really is an active thing. You can grow up attending mass every week, participating in the sacraments, but to really have faith, you have to choose to believe in something. Family is at the heart of this novel, and Sheila's family has its troubles, like most. She says: We are a family of secrets. Without knowing quite how I knew it, I understood what might be said, and what must be quiet. If from the outside the rules appeared arbitrary, from the inside they were perfectly clear. I suspect that Sheila's family is not as unlike other families as she believes. I think many people reading this book will relate to the McGann/Breen family. What I like about Haigh's books is that the characters are so real, you think that you actually know them. Father Art is the most well drawn. He is a lonely man, even as a youth; perhaps being a stepson and stepbrother added to that sense of being different. As a priest, Art cannot marry or have a family of his own, and this isolation hurts him. His loneliness is palpable, and when he meets the young boy and his drug-addicted mother, he feels a sense of family and belonging. The least well drawn character is Art's mother. Sheila and Mike do not like their mother, they make many cutting comments about her, but I was never clear exactly what she had done to warrant this dislike. She seems to be very distant from her children, and perhaps the author made her character less clear to her children to emphasize that distance. Faith is an emotional ride, and it affected me deeply. Days later, I find myself still thinking about Father Art, my heart aching for him. The writing is superb, the characters are so real. It is simply the best book I have read this year. It ranks up with Emma Donoghue's amazing Room in the emotions that I felt when I read it. I grew up in a Catholic family, and that part of the story resonates with me, but you do not have to be Catholic to appreciate the richness of this story. If you have siblings, you will understand the feelings here.
This novel is set in Boston during 2002---the days of the "witch hunt" for priests who abused children. An Irish priest is accused. The story is told by his sister, and there are no difficult parts to read about any sexual abuse. His sister investigates the allegations and presents testimony for the reader to judge if the priest was guilty. A younger brother discovers other evidence that is crucial, but he does not reveal it. The plot and characterization is great. My book discussion group enjoyed this novel and the earlier Haigh novel The Condition.
Ah, the pedophile priest scandal. No matter what you say about it, somebody will be angry at you. I can't think of a single person who isn't disgusted and outraged by child molestation - and rightfully so. The controversy is in the way the Catholic Church responded. Full disclosure time: I'm not Catholic, but my parents are. (They converted after my brother and I were grown up.) More disclosure: I disagree with a lot of the policies of the Catholic Church. (Hey, if I agreed, I'd be Catholic myself.) I will say this: there are some good things about Catholicism - the long tradition of learning and scholarship, the spirit of reaching out to those in need, the vivid imagination that informs their lore, and the sheer beauty of their churches and rituals. BUT - appreciating the good things about Catholicism does not excuse child molestation. "Ever. Nor does it excuse those situations where abuse occurred and the perpetrator was simply moved to another locality, or sent to "treatment" without a court hearing. If nothing else, those kids deserved to have their grievance heard under the laws of this land - I don't care WHO the perp is, he can damn well go to a civilian court (and a civilian prison if found guilty.) Lecture over. Now that I've ticked everybody off, let's talk about the book. The main character, Sheila, is caught between her two brothers - one an accused priest, the other a man who has his own dysfunctional ties to the alleged victim. The story of Sheila is well played - she grew up in this whole Boston Irish Catholic milieu, and it seems like she never did feel comfortable in it, and escaped to live her own kind of life. I can relate to feeling estranged from the atmosphere you grew up in. But Sheila, like most of us, still loves her family, and the crisis and heartbreak draw her right back in. Think about it: a brother you love is accused of a terrible crime. What would be worse: finding out that he did it, or finding out that he was falsely accused and all of your lives were damaged for nothing? It's a pretty intense book, and it will make you think about your own family ties, and the future of the Catholic Church.
My first Nook book. I walked around the house with it for two days. Read in bed in the morning and at night. Thought-provoking. Infuriating. Heart-stopping. Without a doubt, I'll be recommending it to my book group.
The first part of this book was slow and I wondered if I had made a mistake buying it. It picked up pace and it really had my attention. It had a very sad turn of events. The Catholic church seems to have no option but to make a settlement. Maybe thats why there is so many lawsuits, some of the alleged molestions going back several years. I recommend reading this book, it will leave you wondering.
This book really kept my interest. It tells the story of a priest accused of child abuse from the point of view of the priest and his family. I recommend it highly.
Saw a review of the book in the Costco Connection and picked it up on my Nook; could not book the down. The way Jennifer intertwined each of the family members in the story was wonderful. Great read!
I've read and loved several other books by this author. This is one of my favorites.
This is a masterpiece. I have not read a book this exceptional in a very long time. I am always looking for that story that makes me say....I want more! This is that novel.. Read this, you will not be disappointed...
This book is well written and I could not put it down. The view of a family and their demons is phenomenal. Additionally, the story was riviting. A must read for anyone who enjoys well written modern fiction.
I was surprised by Faith. I¿ll admit it. And I¿ll refrain from any corny puns about my lack of ¿faith¿ in a book titled Faith. Oh well.. well, I tried!So I figured this to be yet another story about the scandal of priests and young boys. I¿ve seen the Lifetime specials, the award-winning movies, and I thought I was been there, done that with this issue.. but I¿d heard so much buzz about Jennifer Haigh¿s story that, when the opportunity presented itself, I had to sit down and give it a shot.What really made me appreciate this book was the lack of emphasis on the actual accusation, and the focus, instead, on the impact and reactions of those involved in Father Art¿s story. Several points of view were brought to the forefront, fleshed out, and really given a voice. I felt genuine conflict as I read, trying to figure out who to believe, who to trust, and who to, ultimately, have faith in. Every character in this novel packs a punch ¿ filled with flaws, strengths, and quirks, I couldn¿t tell you which character had a greater impact on me. I do think the blurb to this book is somewhat misleading, because although the majority of the book is told from Sheila¿s point of view, there is no central character, unless you count the character upon whom disaster has fallen.This is a book of sincere, gut-wrenching family drama. It studies with minute detail the relationships of a blended family, the resilience of faith, the faults in organized religion, and the defects we all face in our own character whenever a difficult decision is placed before us, and we¿re unable to avoid the temptation to say ¿yes¿.
This will be one of my top ten reads for the year. It is essentially a story less about a priest accused sexual abuse of of young boy and more about the lonely,isolated from normal, human, intimate interaction that is the Roman Catholic priesthood.The writing style was wonderful. The characters were vivid. This book would make for a great book club choice.
A heavy topic to tackle, this book takes on what happens when a priest is accused of the unthinkable. Well intentioned and with potential I found the book to be halting and the characters to be less than well-developed.
I enjoyed The Condition more than I expected, so I thought I'd give this one a shot. & indeed I enjoyed it more than I expected. It was full of psychological truth, in the sense that the characters behaved in character. More is revealed about all the participants, bit by bit.
This novel speaks to faith on many levels ¿ a priest¿s faith in God, a sister¿s faith in her brother, a mother¿s faith to her religion, a public¿s faith to the media. Father Arthur Breen has been accused of the worst thing a priest can be accused of doing and is relieved of his duties. In a nearly Christ-like imitation, he does nothing to clear his good name or even defend himself. His thoughts are still only for the accuser and her son, both of whom he loves. Author Jennifer Haigh does a masterful job of creating characters that are real in every sense of the word and of dealing with a highly explosive subject with a meaningful and caring touch.
This is the story of a family. A family who shows the world a little and hides a whole lot--even from each other. It's a story of compassion and abuse, lies and secrets, of people who once could finish each other sentences and now don't know who they themselves are, let alone who the people their family have become. It's a story of the many ways love can be given, but also withheld. It's about narrow minds and big dreams--it's about the day to day and it's profound effect on the future. It's about how sometimes grace and sin can be the exact same thing, and how that fact can tear apart hearts and lives. There are so many exquisite dimensions to this book, you really must experience it for yourself to understand. And if that understanding moves you as much as it did me, then we've both spent our time wisely and well.
I'd heard a lot of praise for the novel Faith by Jennifer Haigh before I started reading it, but I have to say that it didn't have the same effect on me as it did so many of you. I didn't like it.The narrator in Faith is a woman whose much older half-brother, a priest, is accused of molesting a child. The novel revolves around the stories of the characters involved, circling around and around until the reader finds out for sure whether Father Arthur Breen is actually guilty or not.My major complaint is that the novel is boring. Nothing much happens. I normally love reading character-driven novels, but in this case the characters themselves were not dynamic or convincing enough to keep me interested. If you write a character-driven novel, you need to have interesting characters.We never find out very much at all about the narrator, Sheila, which I think was intentional, but maddening just the same. The rest of the characters don't get very interesting until the end. Father Breen, Mike McGann, Ted McGann, Aiden, even Kath Conlon are all stock characters - they mostly do just what you expect them to do and don't have a whole lot of unique personality. They were convincing as characters in a book, but not as real people. And who wants to read about characters in a book?One of the points of Faith, I think, is to get the reader to consider the Catholic Church and the problems and issues within it. I'm not Catholic - maybe if I was these internal failings would be more important to me. As it stands, a novel I read last year, Vestments by John Reimringer, was a much more convincing commentary on the Catholic Church. In Vestments, the story thrust the reader inside the inner workings of the Church. The issues being raised, which were, in reality, less despicable (no pedophilia), seemed much more shocking and gritty. In Faith, the narrator, and therefore the reader, are outsiders standing on the periphery hearing about these things happening rather than experiencing them happening.Overall, I was not impressed. It wasn't awful, but it wasn't great, either.
I am a cradle Catholic. My parents were always active in our local parish. We even attended what we called Family Camp, a week long family retreat run by Fr. R, a Roman Catholic priest I loved to death. With all the typical boredom associated with having to go to Mass every week and not a small amount of ever-present guilt, my faith life, that of my family and that of our family's friends was a stable, comforting and accepting place to grow up. It wasn't until I was an adult when the sexual abuse scandals hit home. I believe I was in college when Fr. R, a man who made faith tangible to me, was forced out of the priesthood because of sexual misconduct. This revelation devastated me. I loved him, but what he did sickened me. How to reconcile that? Then, not too many years ago, my Dad called me. I love him, but he never calls me with good news. He called to let me know that the priest who led me through Confirmation and got me involved in the Church in a more adult capacity had been defrocked because of sexual abuse that took place during his early priesthood. Again, how do you reconcile a man you loved with a man who harmed and terrorized other children? When you continue to love the man who did these things, you feel like a traitor to those who suffered. Turning your back on him makes you feel like a traitor to all of the good things he brought into your life. It's my experience that the Church's child sex abuse scandals hurts each and everyone of us. It is this personal experience that I brought to the table when I began reading Faith.Sheila McGann, the oldest child from her mother's second marriage, rarely returns home to Boston. Although she loves her brothers, Art Breen from her mother's first marriage, and Mike, her younger full-brother, she has escaped from the dysfunction of growing up in an alcoholic father and a devoutly Catholic mother. It is no secret to either Shelia or Mike that their mother favors her oldest son. Art was much older than both of them. He joined the seminary when they were little. On top of that, Sheila has long since left the church and is unmarried, much to her mother's disapproval. She is obligated to return to Boston when she discovers that her brother has been accused of sexually abusing a young boy who was in his care. Sheila, knowing her brother like she does, does not believe Art to be capable of such an atrocity. While one might think that this would bring mother and daughter closer together, it does not. Sheila's convictions also put her at odds with Mike. He questions Art's innocence so much that he attempts to investigate the case and learn for sure one way or the other. As the father of three sons, he can't stomach the idea of anyone abusing little children and living. Even the bonds that do exist in the McGann family are hobbled by the news.This is my first Jennifer Haigh novel, so I didn't anymore know what to expect from her writing than I did from her approach to this subject matter. I was blown away by the beauty of her words. There was something so familiar about her turns of phrase and about the way she unraveled this story of abuse and family secrets. I simply couldn't resist reading with a pen in hand to mark especially meaningful passages. I'd like to share two of them with you:In my fantasy we sit together in her quiet kitchen, just us two. I open my heart to her and lay it on the table between us. I am still child enough to wish it were possible, adult enough to know it isn't. We are too much ourselves, the people we have always been. (page 22)Art's news was unspeakable, by him or by anyone. I didn't take this personally. If I felt excluded, injured and aggrieved, that bolus of emotion was at least familiar. It attends all my dealings with my family, and theirs with me. Every one of us limps from old wounds. In a perverse way, they entertain us. We poke each other's tender places with a stick. (page 82)The sexual abuse scandals leave the Catholic Church vulnerable and most
The author does a good job of taking a difficult subject and making it humane. The story is told through the sister of a priest accused of molesting a child. It is a very interesting read, the characters are well developed and the reader is curious to find out the truth of what really happened. If the reader is willing to take some risks with such an emotional topic, they will find some human truths, delve into family dynamics and responses to crisis and sibling relationships.
At first I had a hard time with this book both from a stylistic perspective and the heavy Catholic content. But, I like Haigh and I stuck with it and I'm glad I did. Faith refers both to religious faith and faith in people. Haigh handles one of the toughest subjects, pedophilia, with empathy. But, it's about much more than that: family, love, identity, and power - a moving book.
I liked this novel, it was a fast read, well written the characters were real, the story was believable.
I abandoned this book about half way through. This review is about the reason why.The book deals with the scandal of abuse that recently surrounded the Catholic church. The narrator is not a priest affected, not a victim but the sister of a priest accused of molesting a child. That voice unfortunately made the book seem very detached and removed. I felt that telling the story using that voice made the story seem far away. The narrator became the main character which for me shifted the focus away from what the story was about.Unfortunately, I had to walk away from the book.
A sensitive and involving novel on a difficult subject: an accusation of child molestation. Very well written and thoughtful.
A sensitive topic--a priest is accused of sexually molesting a young boy--on so many levels. Jennifer Haigh is brave to attempt a defense--in essence "hurt people hurt people"--that invites the reader to view the priests as former victims themselves. Father Arthur Breen, the accused, typifies the easy mark: quiet, obedient, misunderstood, physically and emotionally timid, different from his peers and even siblings. Haigh traces Arthur's stunted development to his father's disappearance when Arthur was an infant. Mother is persuaded to have the marriage annulled and later remarries, a loud, irascible alcoholic with whom she bears 2 more children. It's a classic Irish Catholic family heavy with things not to be mentioned, never mind discussed (such as Mother's first marriage). Arthur puts one in mind of a good Catholic girl who negotiates family and Church rules with a high degree of observance, not without incurring huge personal deficits. Is it sad? Is it understandable? Yes. Does it excuse the rampant sexual abuse throughout the Catholic Church? No. Without losing focus on Arthur's story, Haigh insinuates with a few telling descriptive lines where the blame lies: on those who knew and allowed it to continue--pastors,bishops, cardinals.The time frame of 2004 was confusing for me: the 3 main characters had childhood memories that would be appropriate for someone in their mid-sixties.particularly with respect to the customs of the Catholic church yet Mike, the real estate agent/brother seems to be in his late 30s. Faith doesn't show us anything we don't already know. Faith asks us to imagine the personal story of one priest caught in the maelstrom of a worldwide scandal.