Feather & Brick: What would you say if you were given an Interview for a place in Heaven?

One night, forty thousand people all have the same daydream where they are visited by God. In every instance he tells them the same thing, that they have a very important choice to make. If they kill their peers which they believe should go to Heaven, than those peers will in fact go to Heaven. However, if they do kill that will then instantly sentence themselves to Hell. If they choose not to do this than they will be able to take their spot in Paradise, but none of the people around them ...