An HBO Original Movie starring Michael B. Jordan (Black Panther), Sofia Boutella (Star Trek: Beyond), and Michael Shannon (The Shape of Water).
An Eisner Award Nominee
"Monday burn Millay, Wednesday Whitman, Friday Faulkner, burn 'em to ashes, then burn the ashes."
For Guy Montag, a career fireman for whom kerosene is perfume, this is not just an official slogan. It is a mantra, a duty, a way of life in a tightly monitored world where thinking is dangerous and books are forbidden.
In 1953, Ray Bradbury envisioned one of the world's most unforgettable dystopian futures, and in Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451, the artist Tim Hamilton translates this frightening modern masterpiece into a gorgeously imagined graphic novel. As could only occur with Bradbury's full cooperation in this authorized adaptation, Hamilton has created a striking work of art that uniquely captures Montag's awakening to the evil of government-controlled thought and the inestimable value of philosophy, theology, and literature.
Including an original foreword by Ray Bradbury and fully depicting the brilliance and force of his canonic and beloved masterwork, Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 is an exceptional, haunting work of graphic literature.
About the Author
Tim Hamilton has produced art for The New York Times Book Review, Cicada magazine, King Features, BOOM Studios, Mad Magazine, and ACT-I-VATE.
Hometown:Los Angeles, California
Date of Birth:August 22, 1920
Place of Birth:Waukegan, Illinois
Education:Attended schools in Waukegan, Illinois, and Los Angeles, California
Reading Group Guide
Reading and Understanding the Work
1. In the upper-left panel of page 4, we see several classic books burning. We also find a similar image on the cover of this work. Identify and describe a few of these books, and then comment on why an oppressive, totalitarian society (such as the one imagined here) would want such books destroyed.
2. On page 7, in regard to kerosene, Montag says: "You never wash it off completely." Explain the possible double meaning of this remark.
3. Part One of this book is entitled, "The Hearth and the Salamander." What is a hearth? And a salamander? How are the meanings (and the typical imagery) linked to these two words reworked, or perhaps distorted, for the purposes of this tale?
4. Note (on page 11, for example, or page 48, or pages 124-6) how the houses, sidewalks, streets, cars, telephones, and people are drawn in this graphic novel. Do these objects look "futuristic" to you, or would "familiar" be a better adjective? What did you make of the fact that the world illustrated in this graphic novelobviously a future version of society as we know itlooks so much like our own world?
5. Can you spot the "Cyclops" on page 15? Who is this person? Describe the mythological beast known as the Cyclops. (Do some research on its background, if necessary.) How might the "impersonal operator of the machine" symbolize the Cyclops, and why?
6. Consider the illustrations of Mildred on page 20 and Clarisse on page 21. These two drawings, both portraits, are quite close to each other, almost mirror images. Is it fair to say that these two women look alike, that they're nearly identical? Why do you suppose artist Tim Hamilton depicts them so? (It's also notable that, in the 1966 film version of Fahrenheit 451, Mildred and Clarisse were played by the same actress: Julie Christie.)
7. On page 26, we encounter a sequence of panels without any textonly artwork. But much is communicated to us. Who is this man? What is he doing? Why is he doing this? (Or are we not supposed to know "why"?) How do you account for the delaythe slight pause, as seen in the middle-bottom panelthat this man takes in executing his act? And finally, what's the point, in terms of both art and narrative, of finally putting this act into "focus" in the lower-right corner?
8. In the upper-right panel on page 30and then immediately thereafter, in the middle left panelwe encounter a pair of illustrations as seen from below. Why? How do such illustrations influence the narrative? How do they alter (in any significant way) our understanding of the characters, setting, or events at hand?
9. A woman goes up in flames on page 40, and we see this horrid event up close (on the top half of the page) and from afar (at the lower right). What effect is achieved in presenting this murder from two distinct vantage points? Also, why does the woman decline Montag's earlier offer, on page 38, to come along with himthereby, instead, choosing to die? What does her speech on page 35 mean: "We shall this day light such a candle," and so forth? What can you say about Beatty's interpretation (on page 41) of her words, and what his commentary says about his character?
10. Look at the "two-faced" image in the middle-right panel on page 49. Montag wears a certain look on his visage; Mildred wears a completely different look. Why does Mildred's look differ so dramatically? What is she reacting to? Explain how the tension of this moment is highlighted by the way in which these two faces have been drawn and positioned. (Is there also a visual pun at work hereabout Montag behaving in a "twofaced" manner? Explain.)
11. Consider these rhetorical questions, which Beatty asks the bedriddenMontag on page 50: "What do we want in this country, above all? People want to be happy, isn't that right? That's all we live for, isn't it?" Could Beatty's outlook be applied to the way we actually live in this country now? Does his (admittedly cynical) take on Americans and their lifestyles make senseor ring trueto you? Why or why not? And if it does, then who are "the happiness boys" (as Beatty refers to himself and his fellow firemen, on page 51) of today's American society?
12. Describe the "magnified page" presentation found on page 57. What is Montag reading? And why do you think Hamilton chose to zoom-in on the page under Montag's thumb? Where else (if anywhere else) in Hamilton's artwork do we perceive the world or its components exclusively through Montag's point of view?
13. Identify and describe the plot-related foreshadowing that we as readers encounter in the panel at the lower-left corner of page 68.
14. "It's not books you need," Faber tellsMontag on page 73, "it's some of the things that once were in books." And a few pages later, on page 77, the old man continues his advice: "Don't look to be saved in any one thing, person, machine, or library." What, in the end, does Faber give to Montagis there anything tangible, anything with a physical heft to it? Or are all of Faber's gifts to the fireman of a conceptual, metaphysical, or strictly communicative variety? (Before answering, revisit the last meeting between these two men, circa page 129.)
15. Look at the top two panels on page 85. On the left, we find a scene of grotesque violence involving two clowns. On the right, we see Mildred's faceand she has an expression that's blissfully serene, maybe even enraptured. The mismatchor, to put it another way, the disconnectbetween these two panels is, on the face of things, almost surrealistically extreme. Yet it makes sense, given the world in which this book is set. Explain this disconnect; account for these two panels.
16. What does Beatty mean when he says, on page 100: "What traitors books can be"? How could an inanimate object be described in this way? Also, if Beatty has such disdain for books of all sorts, then why do you suppose he knows so much about them?
17. Why does Montag think to himself, on page 121, "Beatty wanted to die"? Is Montag correct on this score, in your view? Why do (or don't) you think so?
18. The chromatic intensity of the way in which fire is illustrated throughout this work is readily apparent. (Witness the intensity, for example, of the fiery colors that correspond to the murder of Beatty, on pages 116-7.) But what about fire's less hostile, more inviting qualities? Where do these show up? Look again at pages 138-145, where the light from a campfire is used to convey feelings of intimacy, comfort, and warmth. How, in your view, does Hamilton's artwork conjure such feelings? Or doesn't it?
19. Near the conclusion of this book, Montag and his newfound allies (on pages 146-7) witness a distant atomic explosion. The narration on page 146 reads, in part: "The war began and ended in that instant." War is looming throughout this story, and does not arrive until the very endbut, until that end, it stays very much in the background for almost all of the narrative: Why? And why does this "war" happen so quickly? (When formulating your answers, revisit the "quick war" comment, on page 85, that one of Mildred's friends makes almost in passing.)
20. Reread the dialogue balloon at the top-left corner of page 145: "It wasn't planned, at first. Each man had a book he wanted to remember, and did..." Explain the importance of this "it wasn't planned" remark. What does it mean that people, when confronted with a society that destroys all literature, are compelledfor their own reasons, and in their own waysto secretly memorize such literature? Why is it telling, and even crucial, that the hobos in Bradbury's novel originally started memorizing their cherished texts individually? Explain how the act of remembering is being linked here to humanity's thirst for thought, poetry, theology, and storytelling.
Questions and Exercises for the Class
1. In the first few pages of this graphic novel, we see leaping flames of fire, leaves twirling in the wind, and water streaming from a bathroom's shower-head. Discuss the elemental or even tactile properties of the art in this book. How do such properties visually echo the story that's being told?
2. In his Introduction, Ray Bradbury tells us (on page viii): "I am the hero, Montag, and a good part of me is also Clarisse McClellan. A darker side of me is the fire chief, Beatty, and my philosophical capacities are represented by the philosopher Faber." Did you, as a reader, also see aspects of yourself in all four of this book's main characters? Which characters in this work did you most identify with, and why?
3. "I rarely watch the ‘parlor walls' or go to the races," Clarisse announces on page 9. What are these "parlor walls" she refers to? What purpose do they play in this novel's Orwellian world? And why is it significant that Mildred's favorite "wall" program (or phenomenon) is something called the "Family"? Compare and contrast this novel's "parlor wall" construct with the Internet, reality TV, and other such mass media. (Additionally, comment on Mildred's desire to purchase a "fourth wall" for her home, as expressed on page 20, in light of the dramatic or theatrical term known as the "fourth wall.")
4. Reread the Benjamin Franklin-related "rules" on page 34. What do these rules tell us about American history? Or about Franklin's role in that history? Or about how the government and society depicted in this book effectively critique that history? Did you find other instances in Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451: The Authorized Adaptation where ironic points were made about America's ideas of itself? If so, where?
5. At the bottom of page 47, we see an array of book covers with titles like "Hamlet for Dimwits" and "Classic Comics: Moby Dick"and next to this illustration, the text reads, in part: "Everything boils down to the snap ending. Classics cut to fill a two minute book column." What comments are being made about the decline of literacy and the demise of thoughtfulness, attention spans, etc.in modern times? Is it at all peculiar to you, or maybe even ironic, that such points are being made in the pages of a graphic novel, i.e., a comic book? Explain your views.
6. As a class, discuss Beatty's explanation of why books became bannedand why they're fit only to be destroyedwhich he thus relays to Montag on page 49: "It didn't come from the government down. There was no dictum, no declaration. Technology, mass exploitation, and minority pressure carried the trick." What does Beatty mean by the phrase, "carried the trick?" What is he saying hereespecially in reference to the powers of a government, and those of a people? Further, how (if at all) might Beatty's remarks be said to support controversial past assertions made by Bradbury himself, as reported in The New York Times (Page B8, August 22, 2007), that Fahrenheit 451 "was not a novel about censorship?"
7. Screaming sirens, roaring flames, voice alarms, breaking windows, growling mechanical hell-hounds, "door-voice" devices, buzzing ear-borne "seashells"the world created by Bradbury and Hamilton is a noisy one. How, if at all, do these many blaring sounds add to the psychological drama of this work? That is, how do all these sounds affect what is already a rather taut and intense narrative to start with? And how are such noises articulated, as it were, within the artwork of this book? How did these noises "sound" to you, as a reader?
8. On page 62, an exasperated Montag shouts at his wife, Mildred, "We've started and won two atomic wars since 1990!" How does Mildred feel about this? Why isn't she as upset about this fact as Montag is? Do we ever really know? And later, circa pages 85-9, what do we learn about Mildred'sand her two good friends'feelings about war, politics, and marriage? Is Montag disgusted by these womenor, rather, does he pity them? Use citations (with page numbers) from the book to defend your view.
9. On page 90, Montag reads to his wife and her friends. He reads a famous poem, "Dover Beach," written by the English poet and critic Matthew Arnold. As a class or in smaller groups, read and discuss this poem. What does it mean, or say, to you? Who is being addressed in this poem, and who is its "speaker"? And why do you think this poem so upsets Mrs. Phelps (Mildred's friend who cries)?
10. In a review of this graphic novel, a critic writing for Publishers Weekly noted, "Fire, tapering and curling, is rendered into a crucial additional character." Would you agree? Why, or why not? Must the aggressive yet artistic manner in which fire appears throughout Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 mean that fire is a character in this work? What sort of character is fire: good, bad, or indifferent?
11. While playing poker at the firehouse with Montag and the other firemen, on pages 95-100, Beatty engages in a protractedand quite well-spokenmock debate with Montag, who by this point in the tale is fast becoming his nemesis. Beatty does all the talkingmaking assertions for his own side of the argument as well as Montag'sbut what, in your view, is this argument about? What's the point of all this (one-sided) back-and-forth? The talk escalatesalthough it's really just Beatty talking to himself, in a wayand the argument intensifies, but what does this monologue-presented-as-dialogue finally come down to? Is Beatty's point here simply that quotationsthat is, books (and all the high and mighty ideas we find in books)can be used to prove, or disprove, anything? Discuss.
12. Artist Tim Hamilton (in an interview quoted, in part, on the artist's own blog, which can be found at http://iconotrast.livejournal.com) has said the following about his approach to creating this work: "I wanted to adapt Fahrenheit 451 as a modern-day fable, so I avoided using that ‘hyper-real' look that's so popular in comics today. The story takes place in an unknown city and an unknown time period, so I wanted the art to reflect that ambiguity." Do you think he succeeded in his aims? Explain why or why not.
13. Why is "having fun" so severely criticized in this work? What's wrong with having fun? Why, for example, does Faber say to Montag (sarcastically, on page 79): "In any event, you're a fool. People are having fun."Write a short essay exploring the points made by this work on both the pleasures and the perils of "having fun."
14. When Montag befriends a group of professors-turned-vagabonds in the final pages of this work"bums on the outside, libraries inside," as one of them puts it (on page 144)our protagonist confesses, on page 141, "I don't belong with you, I've been an idiot all the way." To which one of the vagabonds replies, "We all made the right kind of mistakes, or we wouldn't be here." What does this mean, "the right kind of mistakes?" On your own or as a class, name several notable figures from real lifeimportant persons known for their historical, literary, social, or political deedswho also had to "make the right kind of mistakes" in order to succeed at their chosen endeavors.
15. Another question about the vagabonds mentioned immediately above: What did you make of the ironic fact that these highly civilized, highly cultured individuals formerly prestigious professors, one-time progressive authors, and so onhave been forced to exist outside of civilization, surviving the outskirts of human culture? What might Bradbury be telling us here about how a society could outlive its own demise? (To this end, revisit the "phoenix" metaphor described on page 148.)
16. Who was Bertrand Russell (the essayist referred to briefly on page 145)? Prepare a short report on this man, explaining his ideas, achievements, and notable publications. Or, if not Russell, prepare such a report for another name that you encountered, and that was new to you, as you read this book.
17. In one sense, this novel, and this graphic novel, can be read as the heroic journey or quest, if you likeof 30-year-old Guy Montag, as his spiritual, intellectual, and psychological transformation from a book-burning pyromaniac-in-uniform to a book preserving "carrier" of the Book of Ecclesiastes. In this regard, who or what is it that initially sets Montag on this path? What is it, at first, that puts him on his quest? Is it the young muse known as Clarisse? Or the old pedagogue known as Faber? Is it the would be suicide of Mildred? Or the murder of the woman on page 40? Or is it another person or event entirely? Discuss and defend your views among those of your classmates.
18. "We're remembering" are the final two words of spoken dialogue to appear in this work (see page 148). So, we as a people will endure and thriveeven amid conditions that are not only post-literate but, indeed, post-apocalypticand we will survive to the extent that we succeed at preserving the great books of our past: retaining their lessons, reciting their lyrics. And also, conversely, books will go on livingand continue to live, always because they have the ability to live inside of people, to stay with people, to exist solely within people. But do you think that graphic novels could ever be memorized and shared and perpetuated in this way, too? That is, in the way that the works of Darwin and Swift and Lincoln are being "carried" at the end of Fahrenheit 451? Explain why or why not.
19. Finally, conclude your discussion with the advice that Bradbury gives us on page viii: "May I suggest that anyone reading this Introduction take the time to name the one book that he or she would most want to memorize and protect from any censors or ‘firemen.' And not only name the book, but give the reasons why they would wish to memorize it and why it would be a valuable asset to be recited and remembered in the future."