Every small town has a moment when the real world abruptly intrudes, shattering the town's notions of itself and its people. For citizens of Marshall, Michigan, that moment came August 18, 1967. Nola Puyear was working downtown at the Tasty Cafe that morning when she received a package. She opened it and was instantly killed in a fiery explosion.
In the months that followed, law enforcement and prosecutors wrestled with a crime that to all appearances was senseless. Evidence recovered from the blown-up restaurant, including a bottle of pills that had been tainted with lye, suggested a concerted plot to murder Mrs. Puyear. But why had someone wanted to kill the well-liked woman, by all accounts a pillar of her close-knit community? For that matter, was Marshall really the quaint paradise it seemed to be?
Secret Witness brings to light startling new evidence and freshly uncovered facts to address these and other questions that, to this day, surround one of Michigan's most brutal murders. Based on extensive interviews with surviving prosecutors, police, and witnesses, Blaine Pardoe re-creates the investigation that pried into Marshall's dark underbelly and uncovered the seamy private lives led by some of the town's citizenry but led to only tenuous theories about the bombing. The book also examines the pivotal role played by the Secret Witness program, an initiative by the Detroit News that offered rewards for anonymous tips related to violent crimes. What's ultimately revealed is the true depth of evil that occurred in Marshall that day. Every small town has dirty little secrets. This time, they were deadly.
|Publisher:||University of Michigan Press|
|Product dimensions:||6.00(w) x 8.90(h) x 0.70(d)|
About the Author
Blaine Pardoe lives in Virginia but was raised in Battle Creek and Marshall, Michigan. He is an accomplished historian, with several historical nonfiction books to his credit as well as a large number of science fiction and military novels. He is the author of Lost Eagles: One Man's Mission to Find Missing Airmen in Two World Wars, a winner of the State History Award.
Table of Contents
Author's Note xiii
Prologue: Delivery of Death 1
1 A Blast in the Heart of a Small Town 9
2 Collateral Damage 22
3 Small Towns and Their Dirty Little Secrets 36
4 The Secret Witness 69
5 A Wolf among Sheep 82
6 A "Vile and Unpredictable Temper" 93
7 To Catch a "Tiger" 101
8 The Quest for a Motive 111
9 The Long Road to Trial 127
10 "Did Enoch Chism, In Fact, Do It?" 137
11 "Murder Is Not the Product of a Normal Mind" 153
12 The Appeal 164
13 A Shadow Returns to a Peaceful Community 170
Authors Afterword 179
Cast of Characters 183
Notes for Book Clubs 187
About the Author 211
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
Great book.The author did a great job in writing this book. To me he showed that the police were thinking of the victim and not just the crime . I couldn't put the book down once I started reading it.
This book reads like a work of fiction. You will be intrigued from the very beginning. The author does an excellent job of telling the story of this true-life event. There is much more behind this unusual murder than you might expect, and you will be surprised by the turn of events throughout. You won't be able to put it down.
Great book. Couldn't put it down after I started. For those who live in the Battle Creek/Marshall and surrounding area, it is something they should read. Blaine Pardoe did an extensive job on gathering all the information and making it into a compelling book. It's also interesting to read about how much has changed in relation to crimes and how they were solved "back in the day". The laws have changed greatly since this 1967 crime and things that were taboo to talk about then, are common things that you see in today's papers. It's the scandalous stories that you read about in the book that makes you think about how things are perceived (i.e. nothing like this would ever go on in a small town like Marshall). If you don't want to buy the book, go to your local library and see if they have a copy. If the books are out, they can call you when one is available.
I was born in Marshall, Michigan exactly two years after the crime took place. My family still lives in Marshall. Mr. Pardoe took me back in time and made me feel like I was there as the murder, investigation and subsequent trial unfold. Mr. Pardoe tells the story accurately while still preserving the dignity of all involved as much as possible. This is a truly great read that takes us back to a simpler time and the small town crime that shattered a simple small town.