Why Mariah Carey Matters

by Andrew Chan

Overview

The first book to critically examine the legacy of pop superstar Mariah Carey.

When it comes to Mariah Carey, star power is never in doubt. She has sold hundreds of millions of albums and cut more chart-topping hits than any other solo artist—ever. And she has that extraordinary five-octave vocal range. But there is more to her legacy than eye-popping numbers.

Why Mariah Carey Matters examines the creative evolution and complicated biography of a true diva, making the case that, despite her celebrity, Carey’s musicianship and influence are insufficiently appreciated. A pioneering songwriter and producer, Carey pairs her vocal gifts with intimate lyrics and richly layered sonic details. In the mid-1990s, she perfected a blend of pop, hip-hop, and R&B with songs such as “Fantasy” and “Honey” and drew from her turbulent life to create the introspective masterpiece Butterfly. Andrew Chan looks beyond Carey’s glamorous persona to explore her experience as a mixed-race woman in show business, her adventurous forays into house music and gospel, and her appeal to multiple generations of queer audiences. He also reckons with the transcendent ideal of the voice that Carey represents, showing how this international icon taught artists around the world to sing with soul-shaking intensity and a spirit of innovation.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781477325070
Publisher:	University of Texas Press
Publication date:	09/12/2023
Series:	Music Matters
Pages:	168
Sales rank:	695,884
Product dimensions:	5.10(w) x 8.00(h) x 0.80(d)

About the Author

Andrew Chan writes regularly about music, film, and books for 4Columns. His work has also been published by the Criterion Collection, Film Comment, NPR, the New Yorker, and Reverse Shot.

Table of Contents

• 1. A Call to Worship
• 2. What a Voice Means
• 3. Other Sounds, Other Realms
• 4. Out of the Chrysalis
• 5. Between Laughter and Lament
• 6. Back at Number 1
• 7. A Timeless Diva Through Time
• Acknowledgments
• Notes

What People are Saying About This

Emily J. Lordi

The most exciting new book on a popular artist I have read in quite some time. Andrew Chan pays close—even devotional—attention to Mariah Carey’s work, but maintains the critical distance needed to evaluate and historicize it. Combining the passion of the superfan with the analytical wit of our best cultural critics, Chan illuminates Carey’s art and legacy while raising the bar for future appraisals of women in pop.

Clover Hope

Andrew Chan deconstructs the powerhouse that is Mariah Carey through exceptionally intimate writing, breaking her talent into its most fundamental elements. This book is an invaluable, deeply researched document of Carey as a pop anomaly, vocalist, songwriter, and creator in her own right.

Ben Ratliff

Virtuosos are the trickiest subjects: as they bespell you they shut you down, they put you on your hands and knees. Andrew Chan's criticism stands straight up. He reveres, but he also explains, connects, analyzes, elaborates; he helps us see Mariah Carey as a tradition, a code, and a curriculum.

Editorial Reviews

08/14/2023

Journalist Chan’s reverential debut traces the shape-shifting career of “one of the most complicated characters in modern pop.” From the moment Mariah Carey was discovered by Sony Music CEO (and future husband) Tommy Mottola in the late 1980s, she refused to restrict herself to one musical style: the first tape she gave to Mottola was layered with gospel and R&B undertones. Despite Columbia Records’ efforts in the 1990s to market Carey as a ballad-blasting pop singer to white audiences, she continued to make forays into various genres; for example, she was one of the only ’90s pop stars to rerecord her hits for house remixes, which were popular among Black and queer dance club audiences (with whom the biracial singer shared “an experience of outsideness,” Chan writes). Later albums showcased “how sharply attuned Mariah was to R&B’s past and future,” including her 1995 Daydream and its standout “Underneath the Stars,” an “ode to young love... like a secret whispered in the dark by one R&B fan to another.” In expansive prose that occasionally goes overboard (“I like to picture her voice as a kind of cosmic seeker, stretching its tentacles into weird little pockets of sound”), Chan proves that despite a smooth-edged commercial exterior, Carey’s style “foregrounds the ways singing can activate something irrational and untamed within us.” It’s a satisfying tribute to a dynamic and influential singer. (Sept.)

Publishers Weekly

Nonetheless, as Andrew Chan points out in the book Why Mariah Carey Matters, Emancipation brought in scores of new listeners who hadn’t grown up on 'Vision of Love' or 'Emotions,' maybe hadn’t even been born when those songs were released. To longtime fans, the initial critical reaction didn’t seem to matter, and the astronomical sales eventually nudged a reluctant critical establishment to come around.

Pitchfork

Chan is one of my favorite writers and an important voice in contemporary music and film criticism. He’s vivid in his assessment of Carey’s musical gifts. He layers in details of his own upbringing to help us understand why certain songs and singers turned him into a student of the art.  I love the way he brings the reader along with him . . . He situates Carey in refreshing context: with Black singers of the ’80s who influenced her sound, and with other female songwriter-producers like Patrice Rushen, Teena Marie, and Angela Winbush, who don’t often receive credit for their prowess behind the boards.

Oxford American

[Andrew Chan strikes] an elegant balance of tone and writing as a critic, a reporter, and a memoirist all at once . . . when Carey’s effect on audiences poses a phenomenological hurdle, he spins illuminating personal narratives only to then pivot towards rigorous close-readings of her lyrics, voice, and performances worthy of Barthes’s Mythologies.

The Millions

Why Mariah Carey Matters makes the case for Mariah Carey’s place in the pantheon of great musical artists and it’s hard to disagree with its central argument, that for all her accolades, mainstream success and her over-the-top camp persona, we have overlooked the nuance and artistry underneath.

The Queer Review

What stands out the most about this book is the intimacy of the author’s writing. . .Chan’s focus stays fixed on Carey’s extraordinary voice, her metamorphosis from ambitious ingenue into a showbiz heavyweight and the impact her music has on legions of loyal lambs, the latter of which is most poignantly displayed in the final passages of the book.

Xtra Magazine

Required reading for Lambs worldwide: In Why Mariah Matters, Andrew Chan looks beyond Mariah Carey’s undeniable glamour and incredible five-octave vocal range to examine the diva to explore her life as a mixed-race woman in music, her adventurous forays into gospel and house music, and her appeal to multiple generations of queer audiences.

NYLON