Women in Church Ministries: Reform Movements in Ecumenism

by Margit Eckholt (Editor), Dorothea Sattler (Editor), Ulrike Link-Wieczorek (Editor), Andrea Strübind (Editor)

Overview

2022 Catholic Media Association first place award in gender issues - inclusion in the church

Regarding the question of office in the Christian churches, this volume illuminates with heightened ecumenical sensitivity the arguments for the participation of women in all church offices and ministries, without which there will be no way to the visible unity of the churches. It documents the ecumenical congress that took place in Osnabrück in December 2017 and the “Osnabrück theses”—meant to serve the future international and ecumenical conversation and further discussion about the questions of women in church offices—passed by the congress.

The editors hope that this publication will help to set into motion a debate about ministries and services in the Church, which has been stagnant for a long time, and that it will become clear that these questions can only be answered together—by men and women—from now on.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780814685389
Publisher:	Liturgical Press
Publication date:	01/15/2021
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	256
File size:	589 KB

About the Author

Margit Eckholt is professor of dogmatics (with fundamental theology) at the Institute of Catholic Theology, University of Osnabrück.

Dorothea Sattler is professor of ecumenical theology and dogmatics at the Faculty of Catholic Theology, University of Munster.

Ulrike Link-Wieczorek is professor of systematic theology and religious education at the Institute of Protestant Theology and Religious Education, University of Oldenburg.

Andrea Strübind is professor of church history and historical theology at the Institute of Protestant Theology and Religious Education, University of Oldenburg.

Table of Contents

Osnabrück Theses ix

Introduction by the Editors xiii

I Between Tradition and Innovation: Broadening the Horizon for the Question of Women in Church Ministries

Tradition, Criticism of Tradition, and Innovation: On the Road to Gender Equitable Structures of Ministry in the Roman Catholic Church Eva-Maria Faber, Chur/Switzerland 3

II Women in Church Ministries: Biblical and Historical Perspectives

Apostolicity and Power: Who Is in Charge? Or, On the Ambivalent Role of Women in the New Testament (Together with a Proposal for the Feast of the Apostle Mary Magdalene) Michael Theobald, Tübingen 21

Neither Male nor Female: Gregory of Nyssa and the Equality of Men and Women Sr. Makrina Finlay, OSB, Abbey Burg Dinklage 41

"I Have Not Written You a Woman's Gossip, but the Word of God as a Member of the Christian Church": Women in Ecclesiastical Offices-A Search for Traces in Church History Andrea Strübind, Oldenburg 53

III Women's Diaconate: Ecumenical Perspectives

Women's Diaconate Theresia Hainthaler, Frankfurt 79

The Discussion on the Diaconate of Women in the Catholic Church Peter Hünermann, Tübingen 103

Deaconesses in the Orthodox Church: Reflections and Perspectives Thomai Chouvarda, Thessaloniki/Greece 115

IV The Debate on the Admission of Women to Ministry: From the Perspective of Systematic Theology and Canon Law

The Debate on the Admission of Women to Ecclesial Ministry: Cultural Patterns of Justification and Theological Perspectives Isolde Karle, Bochum 131

Jesus Was a Man …-So What? A Functional and Nonsexualized Understanding of Ministry in Anthropological Terms Saskia Wendel, Cologne 143

Women in Church Ministries: Perspectives of a Theology of Ecclesiastical Offices after Vatican II and the Authority of Ordinatio Sacerdotalis Margil Eckholt, Osnabruck 153

Apostolicity-A Vocation Founded in the Resurrection Christ Event Dorothea Sattler, Münster 183

Equality in the Church-But Stopping Short of the Sacrament of Ordination? On the Binding Nature of Dogma and Processes of Decision-Making in the Church with Regard to Ecclesiastical Offices for Women-From the Perspective of Canon Law Sabine Demel, Regensburg 191

V Broadening the Horizon: Pastoral Perspectives

A Fresh Breeze? On the Potential of Women Pastors for Renewal in the Protestant Church Ulrike Link-Wieczorek, Oldenburg 203

Women in the Catholic Church-A Look at the Church in the Philippines Sr. Mary John Mananzan, OSB, Manila/Philippines 215

Osnabruck Theses 227

Authors 237

Editorial Reviews

Women in Church Ministries provides scientific evidence that there is a very old tradition of women’s participation in different church ministries and offices. This is an extremely important book because it gives back the debate on the role of women in the Church to theological arguments in an ecumenical and global framework and with a pastoral perspective. It is both possible and urgent to talk about women in church ministries theologically, without resorting to arguments of cultural politics.”
Massimo Faggioli, Villanova University

“Women in Church Ministries systematically dismantles the arguments—theological and otherwise—used to justify the exclusion of women from ordination in the Catholic Church. This is an excellent resource for those committed to the women’s diaconate and for those interested in carving out a larger place for women in the Catholic Church. These pages invite conversation partners as they explore alternative pathways forward for women and provide inspiring examples of women who redefine the boundaries of their role within the Church.”
Sarah Kohles, OSF, author of In Our Own Words: Religious Life in a Changing World

“’What’s behind the door?’ This brilliant and multi-faceted discussion of women in church ministry is a must-read as we continue to walk the path toward visible Christian unity. Anyone interested in the potential of women for church leadership, both lay and ordained, will find in this volume a wide array of stimulating insights and questions. This courageous and scholarly collection of essays will challenge its readers to look beyond the answers of yesteryear to discover new and vital perspectives.”
Rita Ferrone, author of Liturgy: Sacrosanctum Concilium

“For decades, women, more than half the global Christian community, have asked repeatedly to participate in, contribute to, and function at all levels of ecclesial membership, consultation, decision-making, leadership, and ministry. Most poignantly these arguments have been grounded in a theology of baptism. The astute, incisive, and accessible essays gathered here extend, deepen, and sharpen that argument. These historians, theologians, scholars, and pastoral ministers insist on ‘true equality between all with regard to the dignity and to the activity which is common to all the faithful in the building up of the Body of Christ’ (LG 32)."
M. Shawn Copeland, Professor of Systematic Theology Emerita, Boston College

“Women in Church Ministries: Reform Movements in Ecumenism offers renewed hope to the enduring question of women's sacramental equality, too often stifled behind ‘closed doors.’ Through skillful ecumenical analysis, this collection not only affirms women as protagonists of Christianity but demands ecclesiological innovation to realize the fullness of women's ministries. This collection boldly models the dialogue a living Church so desperately needs to free itself from harmful paradigms to more deeply embody our baptismal equality.”
Kate McElwee, Executive Director, Women’s Ordination Conference


"The presentations of the Osnabrück Congress reveal that even within their own denominations women are having different experiences of their roles in the church. Sharing those experiences in the light of a theologically critiqued tradition, may be just the common ground necessary for a further visible and dynamic Christian unity. This book is an important resource for continuing the momentum on the historical development of ecclesiastical ministries by making them open to all."
Catholic Books Review


"Women in Church Ministries gives the history of the discussion, puts it in context, and makes a good contribution to knowledge."
Virginia Miller, Charles Sturt University, Canberra, Australia, Exchange

"These are brave contributions. It is hoped that they will be heard by the Roman Catholic hierarchy."
Modern Believing

 

"Women in Church Ministries provides pointed theoretical examinations of social and theological issues in a variety of contexts, across different instantiations of Christianity. The entire volume shows how vital ecumenical reflection is for both scholarly endeavors and practical applications."
Journal of Orthodox Christian Studies

From the Publisher