Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date.

For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now.

Consider Lily

Consider Lily

4.6 12
by Anne Dayton, May Vanderbilt

See All Formats & Editions

A tale of love, trials, and faith set against a wonderfully drawn portrait of San Francisco, Consider Lily is chick lit with a heart.
Lily Traywick thinks she must have been adopted. It’s easier than believing she’s actually related to Jane and Roland Traywick, her power-couple parents who own Traywick’s of San Francisco, the most chichi


A tale of love, trials, and faith set against a wonderfully drawn portrait of San Francisco, Consider Lily is chick lit with a heart.
Lily Traywick thinks she must have been adopted. It’s easier than believing she’s actually related to Jane and Roland Traywick, her power-couple parents who own Traywick’s of San Francisco, the most chichi department store on the West Coast. While her parents party with Muccia in Milan and Gabbana in Paris, Lily hangs out at home in ratty jeans and an old T-shirt. She loves softball, guys, and Jesus, and she’s eager to make her own way in the world. Feeling that her life is on hold, she turns to her best friend Reagan Axness. Reagan, a fashionista who has it all, offers just the solution: a major life makeover.

Lily is soon dressing in the latest must-have fashions and pursuing a writing career. She’s even dating the “perfect” guy. But does he love her for who she really is? And will he be able to resist the tempting seductress who has her eye on him? As Lily’s old friends question her new way of life, and public scandal, family drama, and technological disasters add to her confusion, Lily is forced to consider whether her quest to have it all will cause her to lose everything that matters.

Hot off their debut success, Emily Ever After, “good-girl” chick-lit trailblazers Dayton and Vanderbilt return with a witty, refreshingly real story of a young woman’s adventures in the high-powered world of San Francisco high fashion.

Editorial Reviews

Library Journal
Christian chick-lit authors Dayton and Vanderbilt (Emily Ever After) are back with Lily, who decides on a major life makeover. First, she trades her softball glove and jeans for fishnet stockings and flirting lessons. Then she starts writing an anonymous blog called Fashion Victim that gets picked up by the San Francisco Weekly but quickly becomes troubled when her editor spices up her columns without permission. Christian readers and fans of "good-girl" fiction will enjoy; those looking for fun and flirty chick lit should look elsewhere. Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
The authors of Emily Ever After (2005) return with more Christian chick lit. At 27, Lily Traywick is still living in her parents' house, languishing in the children's department of their San Francisco department store and beginning to think that she's never going to go on a real date. Which is when she decides to let her chic best friend give her a makeover-not just new clothes and a haircut, but an apartment in the city and flirting lessons, too. Thus transformed, Lily attracts the attentions of Sam: surfer, law student and Christian. Lily makes frequent mention of her own commitment to Christianity, but this seems less like an expression of real faith than a crass attempt on the part of the authors to attract a niche audience. The spiritual challenges she faces tend to be on the order of whether or not to wear a bikini to a pool party. The problem of modest dress in a half-naked world is a potentially compelling one, but Dayton and Vanderbilt fail to explore it with any level of thoughtfulness. Instead, they simply give Lily the bikini-and a sarong. It's worth noting that, while Jesus is silent on the topic of swimwear, he has a lot to say about kindness and tolerance, neither of which Lily demonstrates. Dayton and Vanderbilt establish Lily's supposed virtue by juxtaposing her with characters-her appearance-obsessed mother; Sam's mean and sexually predatory friend, Delia; the cold and aggressively Christian Alexandra-who are venal to the point of caricature. Even this strategy fails, though, since Lily's scornful mockery of these straw women reflects at least as poorly on her as it does on them. It's not simply that Lily is not a good person, it's that she doesn't even try to be one,and neither she nor her creators notice or care until she hurts everyone she knows with a tell-all blog-and even then, she gets off easy: Her friends and family exhibit far more charity than she ever does. Any reader who takes her faith seriously will be unimpressed by Lily's smug, shallow brand of Christianity.

Product Details

The Crown Publishing Group
Publication date:
Product dimensions:
5.50(w) x 8.20(h) x 0.90(d)

Read an Excerpt

Consider Lily

By Anne Dayton and May Vanderbilt

Random House

Anne Dayton and May Vanderbilt
All right reserved.

ISBN: 1400072565

Chapter One

The Spotlights swirl and then land on the back of the catwalk in one solid beam. I hold my breath. This is it.
The first model stands at the end of the runway. She's wearing a Diesel swimsuit and strappy high heels. She gives me a big smile and begins to strut down the catwalk, just like we practiced. Someone asks me a question through my headset, and I answer quietly. I look around at the seated crowd of glittering A-listers. They're nodding their heads in approval, and the fashion journalists are taking frantic notes. Flashes are popping. I glance at my mother at the back of the crowd. She looks like she's watching Schindler's List. I take a deep breath. It's going just fine. It's going to be the best fashion show San Francisco has ever seen.
And it will all be because of me and my hard work.
I try to read the crowd's reaction to the first model. I begged and pleaded with Mom to let me use the fashion show as a benefit for the San Francisco YWCA. She agreed, reluctantly, saying she hoped that this would help us get extra press. All of the clothes worn today by the models will be auctioned off to benefit the girls club. I'm going to give something back to the city and prove myself to my parents.
I am the only child of Roland and Joan Traywick--the über--fashion couple who madePrada a household name in the Bay Area. They are the clothiers behind the most high-end department store in the city. Traywick's of San Francisco. The haute couture temple of my mockery. Tomboy. Awkward. Wallflower. Late bloomer. Ugly duckling. Old maid. That's me. Lily Opal Frances Traywick. Hear me roar! (Actually hear my grandmothers roar, since each insisted I be named after her, hence my crazy middle names.) I still can't believe my parents trusted me with organizing the annual Traywick's spring fashion show. If all goes well, this could be my chance out of my pastel prison, the Silver Spoon, the Traywick's children's wear department. Management position here I come.
I didn't always want to work in the children's department. In fact, the plan was to avoid fashion at all costs. Having grown up at my parent's store, I was desperate to strike out on my own. However, I was forced to abandon my immediate postcollege plan, which was writing a bestselling novel, when I realized that the only plots I could think of were old episodes of Saved by the Bell. Next I applied at the Family Crisis Intervention Center so I could make my mark in this world, help my fellow man, ask not what this country can do for me but . . . is that my salary?! Sadly, things didn't work out at the Intervention Center.
That's when my parents offered me a job at the store. At first I scoffed at their generosity, but as my bills started to pile up, I came around to the idea. It was no secret I was expected to take over the store someday. I guess that's why they felt justified in inflicting on me their ridiculous philosophy, "hard work is good for you," which directly translated means, no handouts, not even for their only child. Plus, Traywick's was home, in a sense. I grew up hiding in the coatracks and wreaking havoc on the gracefully ascending escalators. It felt safe, and I knew I'd get something else soon enough. Now it just feels like my tombstone will read It was supposed to be temporary. I guess the road to
hell, or Traywick's, is paved with good intentions. In the four years I've been rotting in kiddieland I've been brainstorming ways to get out. So when Dad asked if I would like to have a go at organizing Traywick's annual publicity stunt, I mean fashion show, I jumped at the chance. He hinted that if it went well I could leave the Silver Spoon behind. It has to go well.
I watch the runway breathlessly as the next model comes out. Shelly is missing one of her front teeth due to a field hockey incident. I've tried to remind her not to smile, but as I look up, there she is at the end of the runway in a Kate Spade sundress, beaming her gappy grin. I feel a pinching, icy death-grip on my arm.
"What is the meaning of this?" Mom hisses at me. As the fashion editor from the San Francisco Chronicle passes by, Mom looks up quickly and throws her a big, calm, patent Joan Traywick smile.
I gulp. "What?"
"Where did you get these models?"
"The YWCA."
"The what?"
I steel myself against her venom. "It cut our costs in half and--"
"This is unacceptable. Unacceptable. I said it could benefit the YWCA. Not that you could use their ragamuffins as runway models."
"Mom, shhhhh. Calm down."
I look up at the runway and thank God as I see Chloe coming down. She could be a model, even though she's not. The point of using the girls from the YWCA was not only to get them involved, but also to show the fashion world women of all shapes and sizes instead of those preening giraffes Mom usually hires who make young girls hate their
butts and freckles. My mother stands with me in the back of the crowd with her lips rolled in like a perfect seam. She won't look at me.
"It's fine, Mom. At the end of the show, I will thank the models and announce that they are from the girls club, and everyone will be moved and impressed."
She turns to face me. I can sense that she still needs more coaxing.
"You just need to believe in people. If you just elevate culture to be more aware of those less fortunate, then--"
I hear the crowd gasping. A woman near the runway springs to her feet and runs quickly to the back. Several others are trying to hide behind their programs or duck under their folding chairs.
Oh no. Ginger. I should have known.
Ginger is the YWCA spitfire, who they warned me was a bit immature. Ginger is standing on the end of the catwalk in a cute little camo-print skirt and white silk top. There is just one problem. She is launching cream pies from the stage and is yelling something about saving the earthworms.
As chaos erupts, with powdered and primped ladies mowing down photographers, my mother finally speaks.
"Maria Shriver has whipped cream in her hair, and the style editor at Vogue is crying over her vintage Chanel. Tell me, Lily, is this what elevating culture looks like? Because I already feel less fortunate."

I roll over and look at the clock. Eleven thirteen. I roll over again. I just can't go down there. I'm too embarrassed. I'll just play dead. They'll come up here to my bedroom and find me dead and feel just terrible about not appreciating me all along. That's what I'll do. I'll just die on them. And since I don't have a boyfriend, maybe the man of my dreams will show up at my funeral--never had a thing for punctuality, did he?--and wail over my beautiful porcelain skin and ruby red lips. He'll beat his chest and ask, Why God, why? I hear a gentle knock at the door and ready myself to play dead.
"Lil?" It's my grandmother Opal, who lives with us. The only sane person in this house.
I don't answer her.
She comes in and clomps over the San Francisco Chronicle spilled all over my floor. She's seen the article. I've seen it. My parents have seen it. And now I must die.
Gran sits down on the edge of my bed. "Hey, sweetie, why don't you come on down to breakfast now, hmmm?"
I guess she's not buying that I'm asleep or dead. I groan. "I can't go down there. I can't ever go outside again. I have to stay here in my pajamas for the rest of my life."
"So you saw the article then?" Gran asks.
After Ginger unloaded her pies on the audience, I felt we made quite a graceful comeback. I coaxed the crowd back into their seats, assuring no more special effects, and the rest of the girls were perfect. At the end of the show, I gave a speech about how the benefit worked and whom it benefited. And then I called out the models and introduced
them to the crowd. Everyone clapped politely and went home. Sure it wasn't perfect, but really, it was fine. Not a fiasco at all. But unfortunately, the Chronicle fashion editor did not agree. Today in the Weekend Style section the lead article was "Fashion Victim." It recounted the Traywick's fashion show as "an evening of garish fashion, fat models, and activism." I was crushed. Deflated. I mean, sure, I didn't mean for the style editor of Vogue to get smacked with what I later found out was a vegan lemon meringue, and it really didn't make any sense that Ginger threw the pies at women wearing fur to promote her Save the Earthworm club. But the article also claimed that the benefit angle was just "another pathetic attempt by the fashion world to seem humanitarian when in fact all the Traywick's Corporation clearly wanted was some good press and a little free publicity." Why were they being so cynical? The girls from the Y loved being in the fashion show, and we raised thousands of dollars. So much for my big promotion out of the kids' department. This was the biggest scandal at Traywick's since the sixties when a group of women did a sit-in in the lingerie department and set off the fire alarm by burning their bras. But the absolute worst thing that the fashion editor said had nothing to do with the stupid fashion show. It was a personal shot. Below
the belt. The biggest problem, however, was not with the show itself but its coordinator, Lily Traywick, who has been working for her parents since she graduated from college. It seems the fashion gene skipped the young Miss Traywick altogether. Not only did she organize the ill-fated fashion show, but she herself came dressed like a WNBA star. One can only wonder whether the notoriously persnickety Joan Traywick is asleep at the wheel where her own daughter is concerned. Or perhaps young Lily is so hopeless that Joan has tossed up her hands in disbelief and cried, I give up!
Above this is a photograph of me, mouth open, looking stunned and helpless. I guess I'm staring blankly across the room again because I come to to the sound of Gran talking.
"I just don't care what that nasty viper woman said about you, it's simply not true. Now buck up, Lil. You're tougher than this," she says.
I smile weakly at her.
"And you're my Lil' Opal."
I laugh. She just loves that I'm named after her. "Love you, Gran."
She smiles, and then the doorbell rings. "I'll get it," she says and goes downstairs.
I lie back on my bed and try to fall back asleep when I hear Gran yelling from downstairs. "Lil?"
"What?" I yell back. I'm not going down there. In fact, I'm never leaving this room. I'll just tell people my pajamas are sewn to the sheets.
Gran doesn't answer. I guess she doesn't need me anymore. Good. I hear a knock at my door and sigh. "Yeah?" I call to the closed door.
It opens. "Hey, you." It's Steph. I have two best friends in this world, Reagan Axness and Stephanie Harold. They're as different as can be and are definite proof of my multiple personality disorder. I met Steph on the leadership team of Campus Crusade at Stanford. She divides her time between medical school, the San Francisco Symphony, and volunteer work, and looks like she stepped off the pages of a J. Crew catalog. Men look at her and dream of raising lots of flaxenhaired babies and tending fields of wheat. Meanwhile, Reagan is half Norwegian and half Chinese and is coolness defined. She has more fashion sense in her little toe than I do in my entire body, and her prowess in the dating game would be envied by Elizabeth Taylor. For a girl named by conservative parents after their beloved Republican governor (later to be the "Don't Worry Be Happy" Republican president) she turned out pretty wild. All that she and the late president share is a deep and rarely paralleled love of the eighties.
"Mm," I say.
"How are you doing? I haven't seen you in a couple of days," says Steph.
"Fine. I'm fine. Busy, I guess."
She comes over and sits on my bed. I try to pull up the sheets to cover my pajamas and then try to mat my hair down with my hand.
"Busy? Busy growing bed sores? You're not worried about that silly article, are you?"
I shrug. "What article?"
She points with her finger at my floor where the article has been since I ran downstairs to see the press we must have generated at the fashion show. Now the article is all crumpled and tear-stained. "I'm so sorry, Lily. It was a stupid article. It really was. My mom agrees with me completely, and she always reads the fashion pages. Everyone says so. It was a personal shot. And it wasn't fair, nor is it true. Any of it."
I smile, weakly. "Right. So I'm not a fashion victim. And my mother isn't persnickety. Hmph."
I hear Steph laugh. "Okay, the persnickety part about your mom is true. But the other parts weren't. You're not a fashion victim. I've always liked you just the way you are."
I look at myself in the mirror. "That doesn't change that I've still never had a date."
"You've had a date. I'm tired of talking about this with you. We've already been through it. Tell me your dates."
"Yes. For my personal sanity, I need to hear you list them so that I know that you know that you have in fact had a date. Now go."
I sigh. "Okay fine. But you and I both know they don't count."
"Once for a middle school dance my mom 'surprised' me and arranged for me to take my cousin Christopher as my date. Everyone laughed. We spent the whole night avoiding each other."
"I've seen a picture. He's hot. Continue."
"Another time in high school, Reagan and I went to the movies with two guys. My date chose to sit next to Reagan's boyfriend instead of next to me."
"You probably were so shy that you didn't talk to him so he gave up."
I roll my eyes. "Finally, the worst of them all, in college you arranged for me to be auctioned off for a date at a Crusade fundraiser."
She's laughing. She loves that story. "And . . ." she prompts. "We had a really great time until his mom called and said he had to come home."
"Yeah. Tyler needed to cut the old apron strings, but I think he really liked you.&


Excerpted from Consider Lily by Anne Dayton and May Vanderbilt Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Meet the Author

Anne Dayton and May Vanderbilt are the coauthors of Emily Ever After, a chick-lit novel about New York. Anne Dayton grew up in San Jose, California, and lives in Brooklyn. May Vanderbilt hails from Panama City, Florida, and now lives in San Francisco.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Post to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews

Consider Lily 4.7 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 12 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
This book's plot has been recycled so many times that I'm amazed there were any scraps left to use. Add to that a religious agenda that's about as subtle as a sledghammer and you have a waste of several hours you'll never get back. Ugh. I gave it 1 star more than I had planned to because the supporting characters, the ubiquitous best friends, were actually pretty well-developed. I wouldn't have minded hearing more about them instead of the antagonist.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
After reading the Book of Jane, by these authors I was interested in other novels they had written. You could "see" the ending coming but it still was a nice surprise. Good Read.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Em_Anne_37 More than 1 year ago
After months of letting this book sit on my shelf unread I finally decided to give it a shot. I've read two other books by these authors, but by far I enjoyed this one the most. The story is definately relatable. I laughed at Lily's sarcasm and cried with her through her heartbreak. The book sucks you into Lily Traywick's world and I enjoyed every second of reading it. It's hard to find books that portray the difficulties young women go through, especially young Christian women, but this book hits it right on the head. I definately recommend this book to anyone who needs a bit of a pick me up or just something to pass the time.
peppermintpatty320 More than 1 year ago
This was a great book, and unlike reading other novels for girls and women, I didn't feel guilty about reading it because the content was iffy and had to put it down. I had a great time reading this book (it was hysterical!) and felt good about reading it too, I want to find more great, wholesome novels like this!
Guest More than 1 year ago
This book was very well written and I was so excited to read something that was a good story with nothing bad in it, but expressed Christian virtues. At times I wasn't sure what would happen so it kept the pages turning. So many times I pick up a book and a little ways into it, there is cussing and drinking etc. I appreciate that this book does not express that, but expresses Christian views. Thanks!
Guest More than 1 year ago
In my quest for good Christian fiction, I stumbled upon this gem! After being glued to the text for days I have finally come to the conclusion that this is one of the most worthwhile books I have ever read. Mainly, I loved the idea of taking a classic Bible story and turning it into a contemporary work of fiction. Also, the characters were so alive, so human in all their joy, sorrow, and flaws. Due to the authors' ability to intertwine Christian faith with real issues and situations, I am planning on passing this title to some of my unchurched friends. That is what Christian literature should be about.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Consider Lily was great. My expectations of it before I read it were really low but I was completely wrong about it. Everything that happened in the book and all the characters seemed so real and the book just went by so fast! I can't wait to read Emily Ever After and The Book of Jane by Anne Dayton and May Vanderbilt.
Deborah_K More than 1 year ago
Lily Traywick is the daughter of the owners of huge and famous department store in San Francisco. She is poised to inherit it in the future. However, Lily does not want to continue life working with clothes. She spends time with her two best friends and tries to figure out why she's not able to get a boyfriend. After a makeover she meets Sam, another employee at the store. Soon they begin to date, and Lily starts to really enjoy life. Then Sam's friend Delia comes to town, wrecking havoc into their relationship. Lily jots all these events in her blog, writing about everything that's happened with Sam, her friends, her parents, anyone she's come into contact with. When her blog's secrets become public to those who are in it, it'll take a miracle for her to recover. I thought this was a fun and cool read. I really like this new Chick-lit genre and this book definitely fits in it. My favorite scene in the book would have to be the hockey game where she has to wear that shark head. I just about died laughing. I know how Lily feels about being one of the guys. It happened to me too, they are so used to hanging out with you that they don't realize you're actually a girl. I'm glad Lily kept rejecting Sam when he tried to come back to her after leaving Delia. He needed to suffer after what he had put her through. To be honest, if I had been in Lily's shoes at that point, I would have been severely depressed. Everyone had turned on her even though she had just been telling the truth about them. To be fair though, I don't know why Lily just hadn't used code names when writing in her blog. If you plan on spilling out details of your life, you can't use real names because you never know who will be reading about it. I did enjoy them though. (Although do you realize that fictional characters always get more hits than real people do?) I also appreciated how Lily is a Christian that is strong about her beliefs (she wouldn't date Sam at first because she wasn't sure) and wants her friends to become believers, yet she is not the pushy overbearing stereotypical Christian like other characters in the book. Excellent book, one I would recommend anyone (Christian or non-Christian) to read. This is a fun read that everyone can enjoy because everyone know how it feels to be in Lily's shoes.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Lily is a funny girl. She says stuff we all think, but whould never have the guts to say. And her bloging episode! Oh. My. Gosh. scary! I'd never face the world after that! But it was funny, too. I like that the book shows you can be a christian without being snotty or mean. shows christians have a humor. This is really great if you have a struggle between you're tomboy self and girly self--like me! Loved how it ended. good plot twists. must have!!!!
Guest More than 1 year ago
Although I absolutely adored the low keyed chick-lit first novel by these two authors last summer? I really thought they had matured as their characterizations of the main charaters in this work did too. Love is not some fairy tale and you don't just say you are better than other people you must live in the bitter and sometimes romantic real world. Blessings and kudos to these two authors and their newest work!