Bennington Girls Are Easy

When Sylvie Furst and Cassandra Puffin meet at Bennington College, that Vermont haven for well-to-do young eccentrics and liberal-arts students, they firmly believe theirs will be a friendship for the ages. From the heyday of college through those first delirious post-college years, the two girls have nothing but each other and their charmingly-decorated apartments to keep them afloat.

Propelled by Charlotte Silver’s sharp wit and gimlet eye for the foibles of 21st-century New York City, ...